If i fail the "Peace and Order" task for the monastery's trust (by completing the 4 tasks required for the don instead), will I not be able to become a magician in the game. How do I join the monastery if i fail thtat task?? I wan't to make a wel- rounded character with magic and fighting skills so I don;'t wanna be stuck with the bandits for the rest of the game.

Also, where is the evidence to convict Cid, or where can I find Doyle? I Spoke to the fisherman guy and told me doyle went into hiding, I'm not sure what to do?

Or you can go pro-order in the harbor village and get admitted directly without training and other requirements.

Where can I find the evidence to convict Cid? Or where can I find doyle? Thx

The inn at the gutter district right at the entry, upper level, sleeping near the corner.
(You need to talk to him and many others before finding the things needed to complete the quest sid has, or side with the order warrior whos watching him.

I've done all the talking already. How do I get rid of Lukor? He's the last one left to help out/turn in. I Killed the warehouse leader guy earlier to try my gold plates back. (Seems to have been a bug of some sort that he had them because I never gave them to him. He just said he had them and wasn't giving them back when I spoke to him) I think killing him might have been potentially quest-breaking. Is there any way to spawn him thru the console?

If i join the magicians via this route will I get arrested and have my equipment confiscated? Also can I still join even if i've failed to prove myself to the Carlos dude?

if Lukor was the warehouse guard then you need him to complete the quest for the Order side but you only need four completed missions and there's six or so all in all so one miss doesn't hinder you.

Are you sure you actually killed him though by finishing him when he was down?
(It's a bit easier than the other Gothic games so accidentally killing someone permanently is easily done if you are in a larger fight.)

In one of the rooms (don't remember which, but it's one of the ones opened with the button pushed multiple times) you'll see a crack in the wall showing a winch below, across the ravine; shoot it with a ranged weapon, then head back around and cross the bridge - you should find the final winch in there.

The Good

- The unique tropical island setting.
- Design of the monsters.
- Some effects such as water, lightning, climatic effects.
- Gameplay in Chapters I and II (quests, interactivity, immersion, situations, etc).
- The combat system is much better than in Gothic games.
- The voice acting is much better too.
- The new features: crystal magic system, scroll making, deadly traps inside the dungeons, etc.
- Monster AI, specially how they works together as a team. They have special abilities and even sleep at night.

The Bad

- The character models are ugly. Also, there're some equipment clipping and extremally bad animations.
- The soundtrack is very weak. The main theme is a Fallout 3 ripoff, and the rest of the themes I can't even remember.
- Gameplay in Chapters III and IV - the game became so uninteresting, totally combat-focused. There were no new towns, NPCs, quests, nothing.
- It doesn't matter if you are a mage, warrior, thief, monk, you MUST wear the Titan Armor and use Hammer+Shield in the end. What's the point in being a mage or anything else besides a Warrior - Axe+Shield if you'll have to use the same equipment in Chapter IV? This ruined the replay for me.

Petty (the daughter of...) joined me on our way to the cave behind the waterfalls on the west coast. However when we got there she decided to wait outside and not come with me and eventually when I picked up the titan armor piece I got a message that the quest "have fun with petty or something " got canceled. What happened?