Baldur's Gate III (Larian Studios)
Page 46 of 59 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 45, 46, 47 ... 57, 58, 59  Next
blackeyedboy




Posts: 11065
Location: Transylvania
PostPosted: Wed, 23rd Aug 2023 12:53    Post subject:
@Il_Padrino

I don't think you sound like an apologist at all.

I think you like the game - it's okay to like it, since it has some great stuff in it - and also, either:

a. don't give a shit about the woke stuff
b. don't see the woke stuff a problem

Thing is, both variants have bad long-term consequences. Laughing

Example: almost all forms of entertainment and arts are fucked up due to woke agenda.
...

This is all you need to know: https://nypost.com/2023/04/07/inside-the-woke-scoring-system-guiding-american-companies/


[removed due to being too big / against rules]
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8284
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Wed, 23rd Aug 2023 16:03    Post subject:
Well, I guess my point is that I don't see (most of) the examples given for BG3 as woke. If a game includes romance and sex, it should give the options.

There are some clear lines, like Baldur's Gate being the most inclusive city in the realm Laughing can't contest that.

But it's not like NPCs out of the blue start talking about their recent sex change or push certain political agendas.

You could argue about saving the grove (and thus "nature") and the refugees in the first act, but honestly, those tropes are almost as old as fantasy stories/games themselves. Basically, nature = good, industry = evil, soldiers = bad, civilians = good, etc. Lord of the Rings, Witcher, ... all feature these at one point.
If anything, it's actually disappointing that the story doesn't break new ground.


The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Back to top
FireMaster




Posts: 13850
Location: I do not belong
PostPosted: Wed, 23rd Aug 2023 17:42    Post subject:
if you're a business and you want to avoid a twitter review bomb campaign, it's in your interest not to be "based" and just do a body 1 & 2 system and call it a day. You can be a dickgirl or a vaginaboy and why even care if some other players like that shit if you don't. we don't have to be that.
As for the refugee part, you can be a dick or a genocidal maniac to them if you want your ultimate /pol/ experience, you're not locked out of that option which is why this game is a good RPG. Your morals or lack of them is up to you.

I think I'm in act 3 in the city outskirts now, and I haven't had any sex scenes happen. It's not really a priority for me. Romance in a video game is rather silly but it's not getting in my way.
 Spoiler:
 
Back to top
blackeyedboy




Posts: 11065
Location: Transylvania
PostPosted: Wed, 23rd Aug 2023 17:44    Post subject:
@Il_Padrino

I don't...

It's...

Just enjoy the game, friend!


[removed due to being too big / against rules]
Back to top
headshot
VIP Member



Posts: 40641
Location: UK
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 02:04    Post subject:


May the NFOrce be with you always.
Back to top
Kezmark




Posts: 635

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 07:31    Post subject:
I dunno man, I just don't get it.

People talk about woke/not woke but the game is just whatever, I don't see how people like it so much.

The writing is poor, the characters are annoying and poorly written, the camera is awful in combat, cutscenes lead in to enemies just being placed right next to your character and as such just fuck you over. It is way too limited in what sub-classes it provides, limited character creation, I dunno... I appreciate they put work in it and there's a good amount of content on release all for a normal release price without further bullshit, but if that is all it takes to have it be this highly rated it says more about the state of gaming then anything else.
Back to top
Nodrim




Posts: 10265
Location: Romania
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 08:01    Post subject:
The narrative got progressively worse, but it really turned to absolute shit towards the end.

The evil ending is just a choice at the very end. The revelations exist just to up the stakes, the game constantly tells you that its more important than its predecessors, that the action is more dire and you are the greatest hero of BG. The way things played out was hilariously stupid.

What the hell have these journalists been playing?! Because there are some glaring differences between reviews and reality. This has to be one of the most overrated games of all times.


Last edited by Nodrim on Thu, 24th Aug 2023 08:40; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14936
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 08:34    Post subject:
I guess a lot of people have been playing SHIT.
Back to top
blackeyedboy




Posts: 11065
Location: Transylvania
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 08:38    Post subject:
Kezmark wrote:
The writing is poor, the characters are annoying and poorly written, ...

People won't see this, as most of them haven't read a good book in the past... 10 years / whole life.

TikTok, FB, Instagram, YT are marking today's people culture, standards and development.

So these... "poor" people simply don't (allow themselves to) have a chance to evolve their standards, improve their knowledge, enlighten their spirit, enhance their intellect.


[removed due to being too big / against rules]
Back to top
Nodrim




Posts: 10265
Location: Romania
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 08:39    Post subject:
vurt wrote:
I guess a lot of people have been playing SHIT.


People have been paying for and playing shit for decades. It was also pointed out here that the majority of players haven't finished the first act.
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29452

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 08:40    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Thu, 4th Dec 2025 07:37; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14936
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 08:54    Post subject:
Nodrim wrote:
vurt wrote:
I guess a lot of people have been playing SHIT.


People have been paying for and playing shit for decades. It was also pointed out here that the majority of players haven't finished the first act.


Yeah, i remember seeing some completion list of Steam games. Many of the top reviewed games had extremely poor completion rate.
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 09:46    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 08:48; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
garus
VIP Member



Posts: 34196

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 09:49    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by garus on Tue, 27th Aug 2024 21:16; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 10:14    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 08:48; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Nodrim




Posts: 10265
Location: Romania
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 10:39    Post subject:
This game is sold as an AAA, but in reality is not.

AmpegV4 wrote:

BG3 is a v,good game btw and it's incredibly rare to say that about anything AAA these days. The DnD suits made a very good decision entrusting this franchise with Larian as well.


If this is a very good game than we are doomed. Ofc WotC made a good decision, they want to sell and this is the Instagram version of cRPGs. They also gave it to Larian because WotC are some of the worst woke pieces of shit out there.

AmpegV4 wrote:
The game mechanically appeals to a much wider audience than OwlCat's games.


Exactly, it's not build to be complex, replayable, interesting, etc. It's built with the denominator in order to sell.

Call of Duty and Battlefield being built to sell is bad, but Larian doing it is alright. Also, it's shameful to rush games and release them unfinished for various reasons, but Larian releasing an unfinished product (again) to beat Starfield and lying about the content (again) it's alright.

AmpegV4 wrote:
Pathfinder is virtually save-scum every single encounter.. and i got bored of both titles and quit around the 60% mark.


What are you on about? Maybe you just failed if you had to save scum every single encounter in Pathfinder. But it's true that prior knowledge almost feels required for some encounters and this isn't exactly a good design.

On a related note, BG3 facilitates save scumming and even encourages you to do it with stupid skill checks that lead nowhere. You can save mid conversation. You can save in the middle of the turn. You have a backup before every action.

AmpegV4 wrote:
Also with the game so heavy on buffing and ridiculous AX numbers any surprise encounter is a reload which sucks. Lets see how the Warhammer one pans out as the second game was a massive improvement over the first.


Yes, Pathfinder has issues and this is one of them, stemming from a system with a complexity larger than life in comparison to DND5. It was fixed via mod by the community, so there's that. But I'll suffer through such issues for a complex narrative weave, choices with consequences that matter, complex character progression, interesting companions, a working camera, etc.


Last edited by Nodrim on Thu, 24th Aug 2023 10:55; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
jermore




Posts: 1116

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 10:48    Post subject:
AmpegV4 wrote:
I've pretty much RPG'd my way through the whole game without reading shit or save scumming outcomes (same as BG1+2.

my friends can't seem to do it Laughing
but it does have a lot of failure states

AmpegV4 wrote:

Pathfinder is virtually save-scum every single encounter..

i find it boring if i have to abuse reload and that game certainly seems to be designed around having prior knowledge of encounters because it does not seem to be designed as a pnp game, but as a min-max combat tactics game.
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 11:01    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 08:48; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Divvy




Posts: 1475

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 11:34    Post subject:
I've spent 154 hours on it so far and enjoying the hell out of it despite agreeing with many of the criticisms here. I guess I'm just one of those TikTok, FB, Instagram, YT people who have unevolved standards and intellect. Also apparently getting very lucky with lack of questline bugs so far.

I think it's better than Owlcat's games, which are excellent too, but I find the Pathfinder ruleset sucks ass with it's mandatory buff stacking and stat bloat. The second game was too epic in scope and the ruleset was stretched very thin with ridiculous numbers inflation. Bounded accuracy was one of the best things introduced to 5e and even Larian does it's damndest to break it with silly tadpole abilities, homebrews and OP magic items. But at least in actual 5e you don't generally get AC's and saves over 20 points higher or lower than what your characters can hit and that mostly translates to BG3. You can self-moderate to avoid the most egregious abilities or gear that shift the balance considerably away from intended 5e progression of things.


ASRock B550M Pro4 * 5800X3D * RTX 5070 Ti * 32gb 3600mhz CL16 * 1TB Adata XPG 8200 Pro * Samsung 55" S95F * Sound Blaster Z * Sennheiser HD-650 * Asus AP201 * Super Flower 500w Fanless
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 11:44    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 08:48; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Divvy




Posts: 1475

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 12:17    Post subject:
My personal criticisms:

Companions. They just aren't very interesting and are mostly unlikable and full of themselves. I can't imagine strangers acting like this towards each other, except maybe in 'Murica. There's a fine line between confidence and cockiness and they strongly veer towards the latter. Just offputting. The IMO most likable companions only join you in act 3. Also, everybody is way too horny and a lot of the seemingly innocent dialogue choices with companions are traps which end up your character being very gay to your surprise. Like you're expecting a bro moment from a line and instead you get intimacy, gentle smiles and long eye contacts etc. The only way not to gay is to pick the bottom-most asshole line.

Balance issues. The game is way too easy on Tactician. I have modded my game to use 150 camp supplies per long rest and I still have thousands now in act 2 of my 2nd playthrough. Should've probably gone with 300+ per long rest. The only way to increase difficulty is to either limit my builds, tactics and gear, which I do, and increase enemy stats with mods, which I abhor. Higher difficulties should add more/different enemies into encounters rather than just buffing existing ones. But I can see that being a problem with every NPC having one or more voiced lines. Maybe that wasn't necessary.

Some minor bugs. Like I said, I've probably been lucky not to have any questlines outright break.

UI jank.

The balance issues are by far the worst thing, though. The rest I can easily forgive.
Back to top
ixigia
[Moderator] Consigliere



Posts: 65436
Location: Italy
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 13:00    Post subject:
The extreme success in terms of gamers' reception and journos definitely was a combination of multiple factors that all contributed to making the product appealing to the public while downplaying its flaws. Larian have been (very Razz) smart about it by perfectly knowing the needs of their target audience and by not giving any review codes to the press until release day, in order to maximize the weight of first impressions which is what matters the most since journos rarely finish games - and it's not a coincidence that (once again) Act I is the one that received the most care.

Then there are all the other elements:
- the game is very accessible for a cRPG, with turn-based mechanics being much more manageable than RTwP for inexperienced folks. It doesn't require any prior DnD knowledge either, you can just hop in and role-bear play
- it comes with a presentation that uses voiced dialogues and well-crafted omnipresent cutscenes, a must if you want to attract the mainstream pool
- its themes speak to the average gamer (who is at the very least about 10 years younger than us), touching subjects and tropes that can hardly impress seasoned players, with virtual bonk-to-horny-jail romances being par for the course. Whether we like it or not, mixing fantasy and real world matters is the norm and complete escapism doesn't quite exist anymore.
etc etc

As for personal opinions, I also find the game highly enjoyable and competent with a nice level of basic reactivity, albeit on the generic side - which is definitely more than I can say about most tripe-y A releases these days. I haven't touched Act II and the problematic III yet since I'm waiting for the first big patches to drop, but even if the game turns into a silly slog (and it will) its reputation would still remain a positive one as far as I'm concerned. I'll likely drop the hat in the future and snag it during a Gabesale.

It's a sequel that in my opinion doesn't quite capture the essence of BG2 in terms of atmosphere/writing and doesn't deserve such high scores (no game ever does), but when I glance at the top-rated games in there then all of a sudden a BG3 getting 10/10s isn't really that outrageous in the context of a completely broken and pointless system. Steam works in a similar way, gamers have been subjected to so much abuse over the years and standards have dropped so low that any big title that is >50% functioning, offers a lot of content and doesn't include predatory schemes automatically gets a thumbs up. It's sad, but that's how things are.



Random creations of an insane mind / Screens from Bulgaria [Early Access]


Last edited by ixigia on Thu, 24th Aug 2023 18:26; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
AKofC




Posts: 4359

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 13:08    Post subject:
jermore wrote:

i find it boring if i have to abuse reload and that game certainly seems to be designed around having prior knowledge of encounters because it does not seem to be designed as a pnp game, but as a min-max combat tactics game.


Just think of yourself character as a secret divination wizard, and the save scumming as him picking the best path through Owlcat's bullshit.

If I was a bandit with 24 AC, I wouldn't be running around the backwoods robbing adventurers. I'd probably be able to take down an entire city state all by myself and have them declare me head honcho.

As for BG3 companions, yeah, only Laezel was interesting to me, mainly because I find her fish out of the water bit funny. The other companions are meh and I haven't bothered talking to them unless the game forces it.


Gustave the Steel
Back to top
blackeyedboy




Posts: 11065
Location: Transylvania
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 14:45    Post subject:


[removed due to being too big / against rules]
Back to top
FireMaster




Posts: 13850
Location: I do not belong
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 15:30    Post subject:
ixigia wrote:
gamers have been subjected to so much abuse over the years and standards have dropped so low that any big title that is >50% functioning, offers a lot of content and doesn't include predatory schemes automatically gets a thumbs up. It's sad, but that's how things are.


This is a true factor, last time I remember getting a similar rpg was DA:O or Mass Effect. I made it to the city (Act 3 I guess??) and it's true that you encounter a little more jank but nothing game breaking or major.
This is still a solid and huge game on its own merits. Had they sacrificed the mocaps and cutscenes they could've opened other doors but it drastically kills the spectacle by relying on your imagination. One can only hope that this would serve to push other major companies towards this route seeing as it did generate massive success instead of turning games into cookie cutter grindfest online stores.
I usually play these sort of games on easy since min maxxing and pre buffing is excel work and I'm too old and tired. The story as the dark urge is a lot more interesting than the other fantasy trope ones I imagine because so far it's pretty decent and gets even more interesting towards the end.
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 16:18    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 08:48; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8284
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Thu, 24th Aug 2023 18:50    Post subject:


The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29452

PostPosted: Fri, 25th Aug 2023 13:18    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Thu, 4th Dec 2025 07:37; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Rifleman




Posts: 1491

PostPosted: Fri, 25th Aug 2023 13:32    Post subject:
"The Launcher will now remember whether you chose DX11 or Vulkan."

Finally!

And this:
"Fixed a memory leak on saving and loading. "


harballaz wrote:
Hey dont be so hard the little console eunuchs, they need time to aim their lil vibratin thumbstick.
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14936
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Fri, 25th Aug 2023 13:37    Post subject:
Patch #1? I browse back a bit in the update history and i see Patch #9.

is the patch numbering some sort of bingo event with random numbers drawn?
Back to top
Page 46 of 59 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - PC Games Arena Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 45, 46, 47 ... 57, 58, 59  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group