The proper partnership you talk about is paying the publishers or the developers.
Nvidia is providing virtual machines for people to run their games as they provide video cards for people to run their games. The developers are already profiting from this, but now they want to sell to copies instead of one.
Imagine having a game that can be played on your PC but it can't be played on your laptop because the publisher/developer wants you to pay for a separate license...
The proper partnership you talk about is paying the publishers or the developers.
One way or another. Indeed, we're talking about profits for anyone involved.
Nodrim wrote:
Nvidia is providing virtual machines for people to run their games as they provide video cards for people to run their games. The developers are already profiting from this, but now they want to sell to copies instead of one.
Not sure I follow you there.
You mean: the developers want to sell TWO copies instead of one? If yes, I don't think that's the case. If I make a game and a third party makes money indirectly through my game, I'd want a share of that. Not from END-USER / gamer, but from the service provider aka that third-party.
You mean: the developers want to sell TWO copies instead of one? If yes, I don't think that's the case. If I make a game and a third party makes money indirectly through my game, I'd want a share of that. Not from END-USER / gamer, but from the service provider aka that third-party.
So the developers should want a share from the sales of video cards? Maybe Microsoft should want a share from the sales of video games for Windows.
Drawing such conclusion from my post makes me wonder if we speak the same language. I'd say we don't.
I was talking about games, not hardware.
EDIT
I would have appreciated a reply from your part regarding the (un)clarity of your phrase. But, since we're not motivated to focus on sense, I've kept this reply short.
If I make a game and a third party makes money indirectly through my game, I'd want a share of that. Not from END-USER / gamer, but from the service provider aka that third-party.
Maybe you don't understand the language you speak.
You make the argument that a third-party should pay for the potential profits. The third party in this case is a virtual machine provided by Nvidia which is pretty much hardware based (the exception being the UI). The same argument you make about this service can be applied to any other hardware product designed for games. Thus, I can make these exaggerated comparisons which might seem crazy but not untrue in the context of the situation.
blackeyedboy wrote:
I would have appreciated a reply from your part regarding the (un)clarity of your phrase. But, since we're not motivated to focus on sense, I've kept this reply short.
Done! You know I'm not an ass and I always try to reply.
EDITED: To clarify a bit: they might consider that nVidia is making money at their expense. Which, in a way, it's true.
That's not true. Or, rather, it is irrelevant. CDproject Red or Sapkovsky have no rights to directly make money of Witcher netflix series, that would be copyright violation. They cant just go and sell tv show or offer services. However, they are making money indirectly - CDPR gets sales from W3 because Witcher is now popular again. Are you gonna sue them for that? No, you cant there the law specifically has cases for that.
If you rent an apartment, buy a PC and install streaming software there so you can stream game from that PC - you get exactly what Nvidia offers except at higher cost (maintainability and setup). But in no way you, or the landlord that rented apartment to you, or the retailer you bought PC from "profit" off the game YOU bought and already own. You play your own games just remotely on your own hardware you paid for.
Nvidia isnt a digital store nor it is a content-delivery system, they just let you rent hardware, a virtual PC if you want. Greedy devs dont want to understand that, they see it as what Stadia is - "BUY MY GAME AGAIN". This is yet another reminder to all of you ye again - YOU OWN JACK SHIT. Sooner or later there will be precedent that will hit you hard and then you will understand that but it will be too late. "First they came..."
Here is how Nvidia (by Nvidia I mean Nvidia and the publishers that forced its hand) will solve it - for a specific catalog of games, like Activision or EA or Ubisoft, there will be an additional (to the GFNow 9.99$ service cost) small subscription (perhaps monthly) or license (one time; either per whole catalog or per game) that you will pay to get access to these "special games". Screenshot this post - that is exactly what's gonna happen, because Nvidia wont be going Stadia way or it will die off instantly. This mostly will be limited by big publishers, I dont think a lot of indies will be as retarded as the Long Soy dev and bother with that and besides, you kinda need a catalogue of games to even persuade the customer to consider that.
EDITED: To clarify a bit: they might consider that nVidia is making money at their expense. Which, in a way, it's true.
That's not true. Or, rather, it is irrelevant. CDproject Red or Sapkovsky have no rights to directly make money of Witcher netflix series, that would be copyright violation.
The Netflix series exists because someone acquired - by PAYING- the rights to use the IP. It means they - the IP owners - MADE MONEY (gained extra profit / advantages) when they negotiated the IP rights usage. They DO NOT have to make additional profit from the Netflix's viewer pockets! The monthly subscription SHOULD remain the same. The whole business, legal and profit issues are between Netflix and the IP owners of The Witcher. The end-user doesn't have to be affected.
It's the same with nVidia, the developers and the end-users of GF Now. It's really up to them to establish their partnerships.
You are taking it too far. I don't think there will be additional fees for us depending on catalogues / publishers / developers. Also, nVidia stands to win more here by having an AS BIG as possible catalogue of games available for stream. Hence my opinion that their 'hardware' is useless without a proper catalogue that people can choose to play from.
A game dev might say to nVidia:
Look, mateys, I want to let you stream my game, but since I LET you use MY game to promote YOUR business here, it's only fair that I get something in return from you, as you are using my IP to promote your services.
Gamers start buying their game coz now they can play it on a virtual PC. Without geforcenow they wouldn't buy it coz their potato home PC can't handle this game.
You are perfectly right. But I don't think some devs might consider this enough. Especially in an age where everything goes by the numbers.
And it's also NOT guaranteed that this service will impact heavily the sales. I personally don't see people rushing now like crazy to buy an 'x' game, just to rush again to Now to play it.
The Netflix series exists because someone acquired - by PAYING- the rights to use the IP. It means they - the IP owners - MADE MONEY (gained extra profit / advantages) when they negotiated the IP rights usage. They DO NOT have to make additional profit from the Netflix's viewer pockets! The monthly subscription SHOULD remain the same. The whole business, legal and profit issues are between Netflix and the IP owners of The Witcher. The end-user doesn't have to be affected.
Netflix is not required to watch a movie you bought. It's a subscription based platform from which you stream video content at a cheaper price than buying each show individually. A good PC is required to play many games. GFN is a virtual PC that allows you to play the games you bought that your physical PC can't handle. I would say there's quite a difference and the publishers/developers can play the entitlement card all they want, consumers should not support this bullshit.
Look, mateys, I want to let users play my game under your hardware, but since they buy YOUR product because they want to pla yMY game - I promote YOUR business here, it's only fair that I get something in return from you, as you are using my IP to promote your goods.
Wanna play mental gymnastics further? We can do it forever. There is no justification to what they do. Nvidia built their service out of existing infrasturcure, but they arent obliged to pay every developer because that infrastructure (videogame market) came/grew into existence naturally. Everyone benefit from that just like everyone benefit from Internet. Nobody can force you to pay for the INTERNET itself and if you build your own ISP company off that existing infrastructure - power to you.
Don't really want to play anything. Especially with someone that refuses to acknowledge sensitive issues that are related to IPs and created content.
I stated my opinion on the matter and since this is such a nice group "mental play", I'll jingle along with a "I don't think you ever created something out of nothing and agreed other parties to take advantage of your brand / work / IP / image by trading services based on your work".
It's not that far "judiciary" indeed, it's actually far from breaking rules, but it's an ethical component that CAN / could be discussed. Not that I'd like to discuss it further.
EDIT
On the FIRST page on GF Now (link here) there is a landing visual communication strategy that marks / highlights... guess what? GAMES! Look, what pops up first? Destiny 2 & Fortnite. Oh my...
What part of "GAMES will sell GeForce Now" you can't get, mateys? That's why I am saying that - at least in communication - nVidia should partner with developers / creators / publishers.
If you so much defend nVidia's HARDWARE service, then why the fuck don't they advertise hardware as it is, but instead go for tens and tens of banners of games? Now's image is branded and created upon games, not network connection or NASA CPU's.
[removed due to being too big / against rules]
Last edited by blackeyedboy on Mon, 2nd Mar 2020 20:20; edited 2 times in total
I am just saying that you should AT LEAST ask me if you can use my super sexy toilet in your company before advertising that you provide to customers super sexy places to have public sex.
EDIT
I agree with the guy from The Long Dark when he answers someone on Twitter to the question if nVidia would have asked, would he allowed the game on NOW.
Quote:
Possibly. My main issue is not being asked, and the assumption we don't need to be asked.
And since nVidia acknowledged this as a mistake and apologized... I rest my case.
Another big issue is that GeForce Now complicates exclusivity agreements. How can you ensure an exclusivity agreement on, say, console or through Epic Game Store if the game can be easily reproduced through GeForce Now on any screen?
Simple - by letting the Nvidia know your game should not be available for play on specific platforms. They can do it with a single checkbox click, unlike Stadai they dont "run in browser" (which Stdia also does not but promises but that is an anecdote for another day) they have dedicated client they have full control over. Dont want The Long Jew to be playabke on Android? Sure, disable it and show the pop-up about platform restriction. That's gonna still suck for the player but ultimately they still will be bale to play it on their shitty laptop and/or decide if they want to buy crappy game or not because it has such restrictions.
Why would a game developer get to dictate the hardware its games are played on, and why would Nvidia need permission to make games a customer has already purchased on Steam available on a virtual machine?
This. End of discussion.
@blackeyedboy
How about next time you pay EA or Activisin fee for AMD cpu support? Good consoomer, now pay up.
How about you read my posts again and see it's not about us, the consumer, but the relationship between the developer (1) and the service provider / nVidia (2). Period.
It is not about us but we, as a customer, are the one suffering from it? Speaking of being obstuse or trolling.
What are you doing is damage control by the book, Great Book of Corporate Doublespeak. You admit there is an issue, but dont even address and quickly shift discussion into different direction, implying that different point must be discussed, but not this. Very classic and as effective as always against en masse.
I couldnt care less about Nvidia. It isnt about them, Nvidia is not the only streaming service that aim to provide similar setup - there is also "Shadow", for example:
I dont give a shit if Ngreedia gets sued to death, but I dont want the case we discuss here make a precedent and become a norm, because in this case it wont just affect Nvidia GFNow but also Shadow and any other Streaming service that tries to do it differently than Stadia. And in the end, user will be basically left with Stadia clones which gonna be EXACT the same situation as with current tvstreaming services - slight differences in catalogue, exclusive to lure you in and pricing parity. If it takes to defend Nvidia to -- in turn -- defend my position on this subject then so be it. And I'm not alone who is conflicted about it but understands the importance:
Areius wrote:
I'm not often with NVIDIA but I'm sort of with them on this, it makes no sense to ask all developers to ask them permission to stream a game - users already own - on their hardware.
Because the moment precedent is set and consoomer sheep just silently shrugs and says "Well, we cant do anything now" - you all lose. And I repeat again, it does not matter how many times you delude yourself into ignorance - game streaming IS the future and you cant change that. That's why there is an active battle for this market. Google was a tiny company once too, but they saw the opportunity back then and seized it. 20 years later, in the minds of commoners, Google now IS the Internet. So, whoever wins the streaming market now - wins the future of videogaming industry.
Spoiler:
Besides, dont you see how retarded you sound when you start to imply I dont just "root" for Epic but also for Nvidia. What's next on this blind slippery slope? Intel? Bethesda? Have some self-awareness and try to pull your head out of your ass and see a bigger picture. Trying to reduce every argument to brand-loyality is basically a Godwin's law in this context. You admit you have no arguments so you resort to fallacies.
just proves google payed all those guys and they want to get an easy payday, they know nvidia has tons of cash, i hope nvidia says fuck u and puts a legal team on it that tells these greedy cunts to go fuck themselves in court
Publishers are such greedy cunts I can't believe it. If I bought the game, what do they care on what hardware I run it? Last time I checked Steam Link Anywhere allows me to stream games from my home pc over the internet to another device, what do they care if I rent out a cloud box with a huge GPU to do that? Cunts.
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum