Chernobyl (HBO, 2019)
Page 8 of 12 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12  Next
TheZor
VIP Member



Posts: 5991

PostPosted: Thu, 6th Jun 2019 11:05    Post subject:
There actually was one black Russian soldier during the evacuations:
https://www.rt.com/news/461078-chernobyl-black-liquidator-hbo/

Of course that actress is dumb as bricks and I generally loathe forced diversity, but just type "her name+chernobyl" and look at which media outlets blew the story up.
Curious, considering they shouldn't be promoting such a person ? Or could it be for the click bait and rustling of easily-rustled jimmies ? Gee, I wonder.

Naturally, same thing would happen in reverse.
Two sides of the same dumbfucking coin.

But I'm talking to the wall Very Happy
Back to top
PickupArtist




Posts: 10794

PostPosted: Thu, 6th Jun 2019 13:49    Post subject:
dumb people can have their dumb opinions, the problem is, she isnt dumb, she knows bullshit like this will get press attention, fuck retard press picking up shit like this where it has zero merit, i bet u there wasnt a single person of color who watched the show who went like, where my N**** at ? but somehow this gets spread, fucking clickbaiters.
Back to top
PickupArtist




Posts: 10794

PostPosted: Thu, 6th Jun 2019 14:44    Post subject:
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Thu, 6th Jun 2019 14:48    Post subject:
It's the Cherenkov effect, nothing to worry about.
Back to top
PickupArtist




Posts: 10794

PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 02:35    Post subject:


twelve days after this movie cam out three mile island incident happened roflol
Back to top
PickupArtist




Posts: 10794

PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 13:57    Post subject:
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 14:45    Post subject:
Waargh wrote:
https://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?depth=1&nv=1&rurl=translate.google.com&sl=ru&sp=nmt4&tl=en&u=https://m.fontanka.ru/2019/06/04/017/%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR0TeMJzctE3eN3ZNF1B8zwtQPIf5VUDjSCqQpypFweUzYaimsNgfwIKVO4&xid=17259,15700021,15700186,15700190,15700256,15700259&usg=ALkJrhhD0oAIM0WSa-bnOeLs5JjxNjJnCQ

Very interesting read

Interesting indeed. The show sure isn't as accurate as it claims to be.
Pripyat was already evacuated on Sunday, a day before scientists in Sweden found out.
And it was Shcherbina's idea to use helicopters, not Legasov. And no helicopter crashed during those first days.
Legasov who was indeed a chemist and not an expert in nuclear plants, and a convinced communist and party member.
The 30km evacuation zone also wasn't Legasov's idea, but Soviet prime minister Ryzhkov's. Legasov didn't even believe in the meltdown the radioactive lava would cause, it was his replacement, Velichov, who had to convince him of it.
Some stuff, like the appointed 3 guys using diving gear (2 technicians and 1 to hold the light), did happen though. Although they never had to dive under water.

Higginbotham's book is a good and interesting read Very Happy
But the show is still very good, even if only as a warning for government cover-ups.
Back to top
Frant
King's Bounty



Posts: 24978
Location: Your Mom
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 15:14    Post subject:
As a dramatization some things were written in order to work better on screen. Khomyuk was invented as a way to present a whole range of people doing the work Khomyuk did. The choice was either to make a documentary or a drama based on real events and I think Craig and Johan did a tremendous job. Changes were made to use the story and actors in a meaningful way and I don't see that as a problem in any way.


Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn!
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 15:20    Post subject:
It's all the Jews fault in the end Very Happy the reason why the Soviets insisted on this safety test was fear of the reactors getting bombed like Israel did in 1981 to Iraq, they wanted to find out how the reactor behaves if the power goes out and diesel backup generators are used.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Opera

it's this little operation that prompted the test, life sure is weird sometimes.
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 16:31    Post subject:


The pressing of the button AZ-5 on reactor 3 Laughing 43 sec.

'Attention, shutting down the reactor, pressing AZ-5!'

'Button pressed.... hey about them graphite tipped rods, was that fixed a few years ba.' *BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOM*

not again
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 16:48    Post subject:
Il_Padrino wrote:
Waargh wrote:
https://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?depth=1&nv=1&rurl=translate.google.com&sl=ru&sp=nmt4&tl=en&u=https://m.fontanka.ru/2019/06/04/017/%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR0TeMJzctE3eN3ZNF1B8zwtQPIf5VUDjSCqQpypFweUzYaimsNgfwIKVO4&xid=17259,15700021,15700186,15700190,15700256,15700259&usg=ALkJrhhD0oAIM0WSa-bnOeLs5JjxNjJnCQ

Very interesting read

Interesting indeed. The show sure isn't as accurate as it claims to be.
Pripyat was already evacuated on Sunday, a day before scientists in Sweden found out.
And it was Shcherbina's idea to use helicopters, not Legasov. And no helicopter crashed during those first days.
Legasov who was indeed a chemist and not an expert in nuclear plants, and a convinced communist and party member.
The 30km evacuation zone also wasn't Legasov's idea, but Soviet prime minister Ryzhkov's. Legasov didn't even believe in the meltdown the radioactive lava would cause, it was his replacement, Velichov, who had to convince him of it.
Some stuff, like the appointed 3 guys using diving gear (2 technicians and 1 to hold the light), did happen though. Although they never had to dive under water.

Higginbotham's book is a good and interesting read Very Happy
But the show is still very good, even if only as a warning for government cover-ups.
Legasov also said in Vienna that the RBMK reactor had design flaws, in the show he stated that he lied.

I think the whole thing was very realistic, from the setting to the way the actors looked, the story as well.
Back to top
WhiteBarbarian




Posts: 6021
Location: Russia
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 17:22    Post subject:
Seen all the episodes. Very liked details how the environments were recreated - flats, furniture, etc. Reminded me of the Grand Mothers places.

Didn't like the way Soviet folks were represented... Creators crammed all the periods of USSR in huge mishmash. Some of this might have been possible during Stalin's rule, but definitely not during the Gorbachev.

Country at that time have already moved heavily towards free market. Jeans, camcoders, vhs players, Sinclair, Сommodore, Texas Instrument computers were up for sale on black market.

Chernobyl incident happen on 26 April 1986, but on 19 November 1986 Gorbachev legalized private entrepreneurship without the help of hired workers. Gorbachev was a provincial simpleton, a harvester driver, so most definitely he was following instructions from various enforcers(KGB, military, etc..) to do so who were already carving there future oligarchical keeps.

Private entrepreneurship was legalized in a very creative way. As long as one was officially employed and did business staff after work hours, one didn't have to pay taxes. So, very quickly workers started to lose part / all of the monetary salary and received goods of their work place as compensation instead. Such goods were sold on various bazaars. Which lead to the appearance of folks who were eager to teach private entrepreneurs the concept of protection money. Less technological goods were "protected" by organized crime, goods of electronic nature by enforcers(policy, military, secret service, etc...)

So, state were still funding factories, providing them with all necessary resources and salary funds. But factories were selling almost nothing back, as their goods were sold by private entrepreneurs as they had no choice. Salary funds were kept by personnel department employees. They also started selling a service there one could get listed as a worker and don't pay taxes as a result.

All this massive theft of state funds will be going till the collapse of USSR and followed by privatization wave in 90s there factories which by that time accumulated enormous amount of dept were privatized for absolutely nothing.

Neutral


Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 17:58    Post subject:
Yeah, the constant threatening with executions or the part where they decide to evacuate the city only after they see children in Germany are kept indoors and such... those parts do come across as western, anti-Russian propaganda, while the facts are well documented and can be easily looked up.
Gorbachev indeed didn't have absolute power, but had to be very careful even, as not everyone was convinced of his glasnost.
But he USSR was already doomed at that point. They were hopelessly behind technology wise, and corruption was massive and everywhere. Chernobyl was the beginning of the end.

I fear mostly that this show will incite more fear about nuclear energy because of how certain things were depicted. They didn't kill those dogs because they were contagious, for example, but out of fear of rabbies. Or the part with Vasili's wife and her baby.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/06/06/why-hbos-chernobyl-gets-nuclear-so-wrong/amp/
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 19:27    Post subject:
nice read.

I've to say tho, that for me, the big danger was the chance of a thermonuclear reaction with the water below the reactor, which would then blow all the remaining fuel into the atmosphere and who knows where.
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 20:15    Post subject:
Sin317 wrote:
nice read.

I've to say tho, that for me, the big danger was the chance of a thermonuclear reaction with the water below the reactor, which would then blow all the remaining fuel into the atmosphere and who knows where.
Seems like everyone forgot Europe was almost blown to smithereens and would have been uninhabitable (most of it), all from 1 nuclear accident.

Luckily that 2-4 megaton explosion didn't happen.
Back to top
Frant
King's Bounty



Posts: 24978
Location: Your Mom
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 20:34    Post subject:
Sin317 wrote:
nice read.

I've to say tho, that for me, the big danger was the chance of a thermonuclear reaction with the water below the reactor, which would then blow all the remaining fuel into the atmosphere and who knows where.


Yeah. If that had happened I'd probably be dead now just as the rest of the Scandinavians that lived at the time as well as huge chunks of western Europe (and perhaps eastern as well depending on the winds).


Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn!
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75775
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Fri, 7th Jun 2019 22:49    Post subject:
Back to top
KillerCrocker




Posts: 20558

PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 00:55    Post subject:
I've finished watching the show... someone explain this to me. So one reactor out of 4 exploded... and they were using all other 3 reactors for few more years normally generating power for the power grid?!

Found this article:
https://www.express.co.uk/showbiz/tv-radio/1137001/Chernobyl-Why-did-the-power-plant-continue-to-run-after-the-disaster-hbo-series-sky

So there were people working normally everyday in reactors 1,2,3 for years? Aren't these reactors in the building next to 4? Wouldn't it require daily 24h maintenance by a lot of people? If they could work so close to reactor 4... wouldn't they quickly die of radiation?


5080 | ps5 pro

Sin317-"im 31 years old and still surprised at how much shit comes out of my ass actually ..."
SteamDRM-"Call of Duty is the symbol of the true perfection in every aspect. Call of Duty games are like Mozart's/Beethoven's symphonies"
deadpoetic-"are you new to the cyberspace?"
Back to top
PickupArtist




Posts: 10794

PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 01:03    Post subject:
madmax17 wrote:
Sin317 wrote:
nice read.

I've to say tho, that for me, the big danger was the chance of a thermonuclear reaction with the water below the reactor, which would then blow all the remaining fuel into the atmosphere and who knows where.
Seems like everyone forgot Europe was almost blown to smithereens and would have been uninhabitable (most of it), all from 1 nuclear accident.

Luckily that 2-4 megaton explosion didn't happen.


which didnt have anything to do with the actual design or functioning of the reactor, but with external circumstances after the first explosion , due to water and an extreme heated object turning water into an explosive material, wich can happen anytime, anywhere near water with some asteroid would crash into earrth hehe
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 07:02    Post subject:
They dropped like 8000 tons of sand, lead and other materials on the reactor to douse the fire, and thus created a new problem.

From what I understand, radioactivity and radiation is very much localized. So you had 2000 röntgen near the walls of reactor 4, but a few dozen meters away, this already dropped to around 50-100.
Not sure how much radioactivity there was near the control centers of reactors 1 to 3, but they were indeed kept active, even during and after the accident. The site seems pretty big, the distance of the control centers are well away from reactor 4.
Some who were in control room 4 during the incident actually survived and are still alive today. Radioactivity is a strange beast indeed.

The biggest danger were the radioactive clouds, carrying microparticles of graphite and such, and the fall-out these cause when it rains.
Back to top
AmpegV4




Posts: 6247

PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 10:05    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by AmpegV4 on Mon, 23rd Feb 2026 09:17; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 10:27    Post subject:
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 11:00    Post subject:
Seems to me like Ryzkhov was in charge not Gorbachev, as he was the premier

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premier_of_the_Soviet_Union

Lenin, Stalin, Khruschev all premiers, not sure how that works in the Soviet Union.
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 14:00    Post subject:
The leader of the Communist Party had more power than the prime minister. A bit like the ayatollah in Iran Laughing
Lenin, Stalin and Khrushchev held both positions, I guess?
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Sat, 8th Jun 2019 14:46    Post subject:
Il_Padrino wrote:
The leader of the Communist Party had more power than the prime minister. A bit like the ayatollah in Iran Laughing
Lenin, Stalin and Khrushchev held both positions, I guess?
Yes Khrushchev was both the general secretary of the party and the premier at the same time, talk about overload. I assume the system functioned differently then.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Secretary_of_the_Communist_Party_of_the_Soviet_Union

Quote:
The 1990 Congress of People's Deputies removed Article 6 from the 1977 Soviet Constitution. Thus, the Communist Party lost its position as the "leading and guiding force of the Soviet society" and the powers of the General Secretary were drastically curtailed. Throughout the rest of his tenure Gorbachev ruled through the office of President of the Soviet Union.

So it seems like Gorbachev lost power in 1990, but in 1986? Seems like division of power between the two.
Back to top
KillerCrocker




Posts: 20558

PostPosted: Sun, 9th Jun 2019 00:25    Post subject:
AmpegV4 wrote:
KillerCrocker wrote:
I've finished watching the show... someone explain this to me. So one reactor out of 4 exploded... and they were using all other 3 reactors for few more years normally generating power for the power grid?!

Found this article:
https://www.express.co.uk/showbiz/tv-radio/1137001/Chernobyl-Why-did-the-power-plant-continue-to-run-after-the-disaster-hbo-series-sky

So there were people working normally everyday in reactors 1,2,3 for years? Aren't these reactors in the building next to 4? Wouldn't it require daily 24h maintenance by a lot of people? If they could work so close to reactor 4... wouldn't they quickly die of radiation?


Yes, it seems they ran reactors 1, 2 & 3 for a long long time (14 years? so sometime up until 2000) after the meltdown. I'm also very surprised that they did this, wonder how much the on-site engineers were paid to do this?

I need to know more about this... so people were working on 1,2,3 with reactor 4 burning and melting around the corner in the next room ? This is crazy


5080 | ps5 pro

Sin317-"im 31 years old and still surprised at how much shit comes out of my ass actually ..."
SteamDRM-"Call of Duty is the symbol of the true perfection in every aspect. Call of Duty games are like Mozart's/Beethoven's symphonies"
deadpoetic-"are you new to the cyberspace?"
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Jun 2019 00:35    Post subject:
All reactors were shut down after the disaster, but once reactor 4 was buried under a couple hundred thousand tons of sand, led and boron and cement, the other reactors (after being cleaned) restarted because the electricity was badly needed.

Oh and also each reactor is it own building and area, they are not like back to back to each other. It's a huge area.
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Jun 2019 06:47    Post subject:
What's also 'funny', in a way, is that reactor 1 had already a minor meltdown around 1980 or 81...

Reactors 3 and 4 were actually built back to back, and shared the same steam vents and such.

During and after the accident, there was a skeleton crew still working constantly in the control rooms. So I'm not sure they shut down the others reactors at all, even nr 3. Those RBMK reactors become very unstable when underperforming (less than 700MW, reactor 4 was at 200 when it exploded), so it might have been safer even to keep them running Laughing

The disregard of the dangers of nuclear energy and radiation was a thing in the Soviet Union since the beginning. A lot of people thought a bit of vodka was a good enough medicine Laughing

Edit: I couldn't immediately find a good picture of the plant, so I took a picture from the book, to give an idea of it's size and location of the reactors. Labels are in Dutch, but I'm sure 'reactor vier' is self explanatory Razz
Edit 2: jesus fuck, I suck at uploading shit from my phone apparently Rolling Eyes
Edit 3: here we go Very Happy

Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Jun 2019 21:10    Post subject:
Damn, i always thought those were all different reactors entirely, just being on like the same Area. my bad then, this is insane lol.
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22567
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Jun 2019 21:29    Post subject:
I know what helps with radiation, some RadX if you know you're about to get irradiated and some Radaway if you want to bring your radiation down.
Back to top
Page 8 of 12 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Movie & TV Sparks Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group