Game of Thrones
Page 55 of 248 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 54, 55, 56 ... 246, 247, 248  Next
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 12:18    Post subject:
4treyu wrote:
Noooooooooooooo! I want Littlefinger dead! Mad Most disgustingly evil character on TV since Ashur in Spartacus. At least that one had an epically gruesome, deserved death.

On the other hand, I loved the ending. Such a beautiful scene.


Littlefinger isn't disgustingly evil. Heck, he isn't evil, period. He is motivated purely by interest. Remember, he even told and warned Ned Stark. But he wouldn't listen. Geoffrey is evil, because his evil deeds serve nothing, not him or anyone else.
Back to top
The_Zeel




Posts: 14922

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 12:36    Post subject:
joffrey is just a mislead spoiled brat who wasnt raised properly and has a skewed view of what a king should be like, luckily he is dumb and easy to manipulate as margaery has proven, also he is hated by everyone and his powerful grandpa is less than content with his bevahiour so i am sure he wont be having a fun time later on.
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 12:41    Post subject:
Mister_s wrote:
Casus wrote:
Extreme characters doing extreme things.

I didn't see many extreme things when the setting (comparable to medieval Europe) is taken into consideration.


So, you actually think people in medieval times were exclusively extreme?

I think human nature is the same as it's always been. Sure, conditions were very different and you had to do things that we would consider extreme today - but not exclusively and I don't think every single person was extreme in their own special way - in pretty much everything they did.

Human beings have never been entirely altruistic honorable (Ned Stark) or excessively extremely cruel like Cersei and Joffrey. I don't care what their background is - people aren't like that all the time.

Martin (the writer) obviously thinks it's appropriate and he thinks that kind of constant extremity is appealing. Personally, I think a balance would make the extremes much more effective when they did happen, because you're right - medieval europe was extreme in many ways. But not because human nature was different - only the conditions were.

But that's my opinion.

To each his own - as they say.
Back to top
Mister_s




Posts: 19862

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 12:53    Post subject:
Are you saying Ned Stark, Cersei and Joffrey are unbelieveable characters? Stark is not entirely altruistic, he has a bunch of character flaws which were portrayed in the books. An entirely honorable man would not have a bastard son. Cersei is trying to draw power to herself by manipulating her son, there are many examples of queens/sultans/mistresses trying to do the same. Trying to put your own son on the throne by killing every heir in sight via some devious plot is a common recurrence in history. Joffrey is just a spoiled brat, many of those are present in our own time. This spoiled brat just happens to have the power to display his cruelty and stupidity.
Yes I do not believe every asshole has the inner potential to be good. Some dicks are just dicks (and vice versa). Not every human being is multilayered, complex or whatever you want to call it.
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 13:16    Post subject:
Mister_s wrote:
Are you saying Ned Stark, Cersei and Joffrey are unbelieveable characters? Stark is not entirely altruistic, he has a bunch of character flaws which were portrayed in the books. An entirely honorable man would not have a bastard son. Cersei is trying to draw power to herself by manipulating her son, there are many examples of queens/sultans/mistresses trying to do the same. Trying to put your own son on the throne by killing every heir in sight via some devious plot is a common recurrence in history. Joffrey is just a spoiled brat, many of those are present in our own time. This spoiled brat just happens to have the power to display his cruelty and stupidity.
Yes I do not believe every asshole has the inner potential to be good. Some dicks are just dicks (and vice versa). Not every human being is multilayered, complex or whatever you want to call it.


Altruism is not about having no flaws - it's about ultimate self-sacrifice, which is EXACTLY what Ned Stark is 100% about - which is why he adopts Snow and treats him so well. Having a bastard son as a problem is a modern concept. If anything, it's against human nature NOT to fuck around. Just like murdering people for abandoning their "Wall" post would not be an altruistic/honorable act today - no matter what. Under GoT conditions - it's obviously the right thing to do for Ned Stark - and he always does the right thing. "The person passing the sentence..." and all that Stark crap.

Again, times were different - but Ned Stark is an incredibly implausible character - just like most of the others.

As for Cersei - her hunger for power is not the issue. That's a very common human drive. The issue is how she uses every single opportunity to torture people with her cruel remarks, like how she constantly takes great pleasure in tormenting Sansa. There's no reason to do that constantly beyond cruelty.

Joffrey is a grade A psychopath. That's not impossible - but the problem is that he's just one more extreme character.

I swear, every single primary character is extreme in their own way. They're either supreme warriors, supreme schemers, supremely evil bastards, supremely jealous, supremely kind (Robb's wife), and so on. It's really jarring to me.

But we don't have to agree.

If you think GoT demonstrates plausible human behavior - then we just see things very differently. That's ok with me.
Back to top
KillerCrocker




Posts: 20558

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 13:37    Post subject:
Not much in this episode. But it was a great watch as always.


5080 | ps5 pro

Sin317-"im 31 years old and still surprised at how much shit comes out of my ass actually ..."
SteamDRM-"Call of Duty is the symbol of the true perfection in every aspect. Call of Duty games are like Mozart's/Beethoven's symphonies"
deadpoetic-"are you new to the cyberspace?"
Back to top
cirithungol




Posts: 3513
Location: UK
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 13:55    Post subject:
 Spoiler:
 


chiv wrote:
don't quote me on that
Back to top
4treyu




Posts: 23499

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 16:55    Post subject:
Sin317 wrote:
4treyu wrote:
Noooooooooooooo! I want Littlefinger dead! Mad Most disgustingly evil character on TV since Ashur in Spartacus. At least that one had an epically gruesome, deserved death.

On the other hand, I loved the ending. Such a beautiful scene.


Littlefinger isn't disgustingly evil. Heck, he isn't evil, period. He is motivated purely by interest. Remember, he even told and warned Ned Stark. But he wouldn't listen. Geoffrey is evil, because his evil deeds serve nothing, not him or anyone else.


That's actually a matter of adjectives to me. I would call Joffrey "purely" evil, but I say that Baelish is disgustingly evil because of the things he's willing to do out of interest in material things, just like Ashur in Spartacus . Those kind of people are the ones that end up being the most disgusting to me Razz
Back to top
beyond1




Posts: 658

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 17:15    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by beyond1 on Tue, 8th Jul 2025 06:05; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 22569
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 17:29    Post subject:
Tyrion - dwarfy, Chaotic Neutral
Back to top
4treyu




Posts: 23499

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 17:30    Post subject:
Aww Yeah
Back to top
beyond1




Posts: 658

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 17:41    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by beyond1 on Tue, 1st Jul 2025 17:24; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 17:42    Post subject:
Tyrion is more like chaotic good (or neutral good, though he does seems a bit chaotic at times) - and Baelish appears to be true neutral. He doesn't give a shit about anything but is not "chaotic" (aka somewhat random) - but he wants to survive in a super-excessively-harsh world, which isn't evil as such.

Joffrey, however, is definitely chaotic evil. Also known as chaotic stupid Smile

Also, they're all extremes Smile
Back to top
beyond1




Posts: 658

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 17:51    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by beyond1 on Tue, 1st Jul 2025 17:24; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 17:56    Post subject:
Sort of amusing, even though alignments have little to do with human nature. There is no such thing as good or evil people - if you ask me.

That said - if I was to place myself on such a chart - I think I would fit True Neutral best. Oh, I realise I'm not a "top member" - whatever that is Smile
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 18:50    Post subject:
4treyu wrote:
Noooooooooooooo! I want Littlefinger dead! Mad Most disgustingly evil character on TV since Ashur in Spartacus. At least that one had an epically gruesome, deserved death.

On the other hand, I loved the ending. Such a beautiful scene.

Littlefinger is badass, and I don't think he will die. He's too smart for that.

If anything, it wouldn't surprise me if it turns out he planned everything from the start and put it into motion by killing Jon Arryn. He's the true puppet master of Westeros.
Back to top
4treyu




Posts: 23499

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 18:58    Post subject:
You're probably right. That doesn't negate the fact that he's truly despicable and deserves to be sent a few ft. underground Very Happy
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 18:59    Post subject:
Casus wrote:
Tyrion is more like chaotic good (or neutral good, though he does seems a bit chaotic at times) - and Baelish appears to be true neutral. He doesn't give a shit about anything but is not "chaotic" (aka somewhat random) - but he wants to survive in a super-excessively-harsh world, which isn't evil as such.

Joffrey, however, is definitely chaotic evil. Also known as chaotic stupid Smile

Also, they're all extremes Smile

I think Varys is the true neutral one, he wouldn't save Ned from the dungeon, but he didn't put him in there either. He only cares about the realm.

Littlefinger is more neutral evil, he doesn't care about anything but himself, and he's willing to go to great lengths to achieve it, no matter the consequences for others.


The numbers don't decide, the system is a lie. The river running dry, the wings of butterflies.
And you may pour us away like soup. Like we're pretty broken flowers.
We'll take back what is ours. One day at a time.
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 19:02    Post subject:
Il_Padrino wrote:
Casus wrote:
Tyrion is more like chaotic good (or neutral good, though he does seems a bit chaotic at times) - and Baelish appears to be true neutral. He doesn't give a shit about anything but is not "chaotic" (aka somewhat random) - but he wants to survive in a super-excessively-harsh world, which isn't evil as such.

Joffrey, however, is definitely chaotic evil. Also known as chaotic stupid Smile

Also, they're all extremes Smile

I think Varys is the true neutral one, he wouldn't save Ned from the dungeon, but he didn't put him in there either. He only cares about the realm.

Littlefinger is more neutral evil, he doesn't care about anything but himself, and he's willing to go to great lengths to achieve it, no matter the consequences for others.


Varys is a utilitarian - and that's good in my book.

As for Littlefinger - we'll just have to disagree there. He's selfish - but not evil. Remember, in Westeros - where most men are super hardcore Conan warriors - it's a tough job to be a weakling with a brain. He has to use his brains to serve himself. Unlike Tyrion - he doesn't have a super rich and powerful father.
Back to top
The_Zeel




Posts: 14922

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 19:09    Post subject:
alignment for s02




though theon true neutral...i dont think so Very Happy
Back to top
4treyu




Posts: 23499

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 19:45    Post subject:
The_Zeel wrote:

though theon true neutral...i dont think so Very Happy


roflmao I was about to say something similar just before reading this Very Happy

Theon is more like: "I don't know what the hell I want, so i just do stuff."

As True Neutral (not that I think that really exists) I would rather see Lord Varys there.
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 19:52    Post subject:
I guess it was an OK episode. Pretty ending - though quite out of place amongst all the senseless brutality.

The best scene was Tyrion telling Sansa the "good news" Smile

The torture scene is the perfect example of how pointlessly sadistic the writer is - and served absolutely no purpose except to shock the audience and make them uncomfortable.

Ros? Yet another extremity by psycho boy.
Back to top
tonizito
VIP Member



Posts: 52346
Location: Portugal, the shithole of Europe.
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 20:45    Post subject:
True Neutral just got fucked grinhurt


boundle (thoughts on cracking AITD) wrote:
i guess thouth if without a legit key the installation was rolling back we are all fucking then
Back to top
zmed




Posts: 9234
Location: Orbanistan
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 20:49    Post subject:
I would put Brienne into at least Lawful Neutral, maybe Lawful Good. That strict code of honor of hers is the textbook example of Lawful.
Back to top
Il_Padrino




Posts: 8285
Location: Greece by the North Sea
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 21:03    Post subject:
Casus wrote:
I guess it was an OK episode. Pretty ending - though quite out of place amongst all the senseless brutality.

The best scene was Tyrion telling Sansa the "good news" Smile

The torture scene is the perfect example of how pointlessly sadistic the writer is - and served absolutely no purpose except to shock the audience and make them uncomfortable.

Ros? Yet another extremity by psycho boy.

That's why Littlefinger is evil and not neutral Razz he didn't have to do that, and if it were the other way around, I doubt Varys would've done the same.

As for the torture, the method the torturer used does hold the clue to his identity so you could argue it's a plot device Very Happy
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 21:13    Post subject:
Il_Padrino wrote:
Casus wrote:
I guess it was an OK episode. Pretty ending - though quite out of place amongst all the senseless brutality.

The best scene was Tyrion telling Sansa the "good news" Smile

The torture scene is the perfect example of how pointlessly sadistic the writer is - and served absolutely no purpose except to shock the audience and make them uncomfortable.

Ros? Yet another extremity by psycho boy.

That's why Littlefinger is evil and not neutral Razz he didn't have to do that, and if it were the other way around, I doubt Varys would've done the same.

As for the torture, the method the torturer used does hold the clue to his identity so you could argue it's a plot device Very Happy


Yes, he absolutely positively had to get rid of Ros. He can't have a whore betray him - think of the consequences. She's obviously a crafty whore - and if he let her live she'd get him eventually. At least, the risk was there. But Littlefinger isn't a person of great power - so he can't just kill her. He has to do it through his scheming - which is why he used Joffrey for that purpose. Joffrey can kill as he pleases - and oh does killing please him.

The difference between Littlefinger and Cersei/Joffrey (and many of the others) - is that everything Littlefinger does is about power and survival. Cersei and Joffrey in particular take great pleasure in the suffering of other people. Littlefinger doesn't take pleasure in that - except when he can use it to make a point to Varys. Though I haven't read much of the books - I'm guessing he hates Varys because Varys is a much better version of himself.

Again, Varys is good and Littlefinger is neutral.

That whole "ladder" speech was too much, but then again - it's yet another example of the extreme nature of this show and how they adore shoving the same brutality and harshness down the throat of the audience every 2-3 minutes. Oh, it's all so harsh - and everyone will end up dead - and nothing but dust remains.

There's a severe lack of nuance and subtlety.

But no, I don't consider Littlefinger evil. He's a selfish person in a position without much inherent power. He has to play the "game" in that way to prosper.

As for Varys - no, he would never have done that. That's because he's a "good" character serving the realm and not himself. He's one of the more balanced characters, actually.

Then again, Martin obviously favors the freaks or the fat people. His darlings are clearly like himself - as in, not very attractive and not very fortunate in matters of love. He was probably teased or abused by someone at school as a child and is writing as sadistically as he can to banish his demons. I don't say this to belittle his work or anything like that.

It's just my impression of him based on what I know and then his writing.

I think he writes very well - by the way. The books are very well written and he has a way with words.

It's just too bad that he's so obsessed with extremities - or it could have been just my kind of thing.
Back to top
Casus




Posts: 4429

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 21:23    Post subject:
zmed wrote:
I would put Brienne into at least Lawful Neutral, maybe Lawful Good. That strict code of honor of hers is the textbook example of Lawful.


Yes, I agree.

In the context of that world - she's definitely Lawful Good. No question about it.

Also known as Lawful stupid Smile (LG and CE are the stupid alignments).
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 21:54    Post subject:
For me, "Evil", is someone who does things with the intend of hurting someone (physically, physically, possessions etc). Littlefinger doesn't do that. The few times he did something to someone (?), it was only ever as a product of his intentions of keeping power etc. Never with the intend to hurt someone. That's why he warned Ned not to trust him.


Geoffrey on the other hand is like "bored evil". Most, if not all, the stuff he does, is because a) he is bored as shit
and
b) he can.
Back to top
4treyu




Posts: 23499

PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 22:16    Post subject:
So you say someone who hurts other people with the purpose of obtaining material benefits isn't evil.

Quite strange idea coming from someone as "leftist" as yourself Very Happy
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Mon, 6th May 2013 22:19    Post subject:
I am anarchist, not leftist. I am true neutral.


And we're talking about being evil, which is not necessarily the same as not caring.
Back to top
Page 55 of 248 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Movie & TV Sparks Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 54, 55, 56 ... 246, 247, 248  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group