Pillars of Eternity by Obisidan
Page 15 of 114 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 14, 15, 16 ... 112, 113, 114  Next
KGen




Posts: 1082

PostPosted: Tue, 25th Sep 2012 09:19    Post subject:
peter980 wrote:
Hmm... is it feasible to have voice overs at 3.0mil?


Hopefully not.

Even if we neglect the budget costs (which to my understanding are quite high), it means the text of anything to be voiced over has to be finalized very early in the development (the whole process takes a lot of time) and thus the developers have to write stuff quickly and can't change it later or add stuff (not all voice actors are available the whole development time on a whim).

In any case, if they will even try to have half as much dialog and descriptions as in Planescape Torment, it will be crazy to try and voice it all over.

The whole voice overs affair are too much of a constriction and will hurt the game more than it will add.


i7 6700k @ 4.4 GHZ, 2060s, 16 GB RAM, SSD, Windows 10x64.
Back to top
Bendi




Posts: 3482

PostPosted: Tue, 25th Sep 2012 09:35    Post subject:
Yeah, there will either be BG style voiceover, for the important parts or most probably none at all. Which is good, as it means more meaty texts. I played and finished Inquisitor recently, which had no voices, and it did not bother me at all.

I also realised something else : "Brain huurts, have to think...I can get stuck in a game?"
Damn you, modern RPG's, damn you.


sin317 wrote:

typical jew comment
Back to top
DraySpittle




Posts: 1115

PostPosted: Tue, 25th Sep 2012 09:39    Post subject:
I'm playing inquisitor and I love it. If this ends up being like that I will be sooooo happy.


NO LINKS TO ILLEGAL STUFF IN SIGS - DLC IS ILLEGAL TOO
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Tue, 25th Sep 2012 23:38    Post subject:
Everybody says that voise over is a bud think is a whacker
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Tue, 25th Sep 2012 23:39    Post subject:
griniaris wrote:
Everybody says that voise over is a bud think is a whacker


Um. I'm sorry, I tried using Chrome's built in translator but it caught fire and shut down Sad Can you please run that by us again, in English this time? Thaaaaaaanks.
Back to top
inz




Posts: 11914

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 00:02    Post subject:
sabin1981 wrote:

Um. I'm sorry, I tried using Chrome's built in translator but it caught fire and shut down Sad Can you please run that by us again, in English this time? Thaaaaaaanks.


It makes complete sense if you read it in your head with a mumbling & muttering old man's voice (as per the avatar). Laughing

Like Very Happy
Back to top
fable2




Posts: 6081

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 00:04    Post subject:
griniaris wrote:
Everybody says that voise over is a bud think is a whacker


My Translator device should come in useful now : Everybody who says that voice over is a bad thing is a wanker Laughing
Back to top
saddamhussein




Posts: 691
Location: not where I'm supposed to be
PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 00:07    Post subject:
inz wrote:
EA's board of directors approves of this deal.



Wheres this gif from?
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 00:32    Post subject:
An episode in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, called "Hush" -- and it's a friggin' good one too.
Back to top
ixigia
[Moderator] Consigliere



Posts: 65437
Location: Italy
PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 00:55    Post subject:
fable2 wrote:
griniaris wrote:
Everybody says that voise over is a bud think is a whacker


My Translator device should come in useful now : Everybody who says that voice over is a bad thing is a wanker Laughing

Laughing In that case, I agree with him!

(as long as it's nothing like this of course )
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 00:58    Post subject:
Ah.. well then I also agree. There's absolutely nothing wrong with VO as long as it's done properly and you don't need to hire multi-million dollar VA to have proper voice overs Smile
Back to top
KGen




Posts: 1082

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 09:26    Post subject:
Who argues voice acting in games is bad? I wish there was a way to add VO to games with huge amounts of dialogue like Planescape for example without compromising the said dialog but unfortunately it's not an option. You either have to cut down on dialog or spend insane amounts of money.

As Feargus mentioned in Game Bunshee interview:

Quote:
Feargus: Our goal is to use voice over as flavor and not as something that exists for every written word in the game. We don’t want to cut down on the depth of dialogs or the number of choices that players have because we are counting voice over dollars. That means, like practically every Obsidian project to date, we are going to push the boundaries of reactivity in our dialogs. And, the more we get funded the more we can do that.


All that without touching on the subject of VO quality at all. People assume it would be good, and I left wondering why should it? Many tried and failed with voice acting in their games, it's certainly not a given.


i7 6700k @ 4.4 GHZ, 2060s, 16 GB RAM, SSD, Windows 10x64.
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 10:08    Post subject:
inz wrote:
sabin1981 wrote:

Um. I'm sorry, I tried using Chrome's built in translator but it caught fire and shut down Sad Can you please run that by us again, in English this time? Thaaaaaaanks.


It makes complete sense if you read it in your head with a mumbling & muttering old man's voice (as per the avatar). Laughing

Like Very Happy


Laughing Laughing Laughing Laughing
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 10:52    Post subject:
KGen wrote:
Who argues voice acting in games is bad? I wish there was a way to add VO to games with huge amounts of dialogue like Planescape for example without compromising the said dialog but unfortunately it's not an option. You either have to cut down on dialog or spend insane amounts of money.

As Feargus mentioned in Game Bunshee interview:

Quote:
Feargus: Our goal is to use voice over as flavor and not as something that exists for every written word in the game. We don’t want to cut down on the depth of dialogs or the number of choices that players have because we are counting voice over dollars. That means, like practically every Obsidian project to date, we are going to push the boundaries of reactivity in our dialogs. And, the more we get funded the more we can do that.


All that without touching on the subject of VO quality at all. People assume it would be good, and I left wondering why should it? Many tried and failed with voice acting in their games, it's certainly not a given.

O, come on.. Rolling Eyes
Every modern RPG that respects itself, have acceptable at least, voice cover.
In old days, maybe the size of the of the voice files - many gigabytes- was a problem, but at today's standards, probably this isn't an issue. And when you ask for help to make a great game, you have to give to your backers a really great game and for me that requires voice, at least in the narration and the opening dialogs, or you deliver a cold non attractive and unnatural outcome.
Only the cost is probably the only reason to cut voices. But then, if you really like your job and you want to make something that later can be pride for itself, then you can accept less profit, at least in the beginning. Because , if you make a great job, it will pay later.
Witcer is a good example for it.
But if your only interest is fast cash, you go down very soon indeed Cool
Back to top
pillermann




Posts: 2577

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 11:17    Post subject:
Only few games are actually enhanced by exceptionally well done VA (Legacy of Kain/Soul Reaver series is a good example, or the unit sounds in DoW)

But just as easily it can break the mood if the voice doesn't fit or just doesn't appeal to the listener(for example I personally detest the English or German VA in Witcher, can't see how anyone can stand to play them with anything but Polish VOs)

Seeing as it's a huge money sink for a hit or miss result, it's better that Obsidian don't waste precious funds on it
Back to top
tet666




Posts: 5096

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 11:34    Post subject:
Dont rly care for vo in a project like this i think it would do more harm than good tbh, the dialogue would need to be simplified and many other things would need to be cut, i just dont want that. I mean the game doesnt need to be as wordy as they PS:T but atleast on the level of BG and BG2 would be great.
Back to top
pillermann




Posts: 2577

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 11:44    Post subject:
actually, BG2 is reportedly wordier than PST (1.2mil vs 800k words, respectively), but quality > quantity ofc
Back to top
KGen




Posts: 1082

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 11:46    Post subject:
griniaris wrote:

Every modern RPG that respects itself, have acceptable at least, voice cover.


You lost me there. The whole notion of this KS is to create a role playing game unlike the games we get today but something in the vein of old classics.
I won't go into comparing RPGs today and yesteryear but god help you if you mean Mass Effect or Dragon Age 2 as examples. Laughing

In any case you miss the point entirely. It's not about the size of the VO files that are a problem.


i7 6700k @ 4.4 GHZ, 2060s, 16 GB RAM, SSD, Windows 10x64.
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 12:36    Post subject:
KGen wrote:
griniaris wrote:

Every modern RPG that respects itself, have acceptable at least, voice cover.


You lost me there. The whole notion of this KS is to create a role playing game unlike the games we get today but something in the vein of old classics.
I won't go into comparing RPGs today and yesteryear but god help you if you mean Mass Effect or Dragon Age 2 as examples. Laughing

In any case you miss the point entirely. It's not about the size of the VO files that are a problem.


What's your IQ' level ?
80 or less , at least that I can guess from your writings...
Who speaks for bul..t games like Mass Effect or Dragon Age 2? Not me of course.
I speak for games like "The Witcher" and Deus ex and maybe partially Dragon Age 1.
They are voiced and have a development circle of 3 years at least.
Not 18 months and budget technology and so...
We want games, Like BG and P.T. in the meaning of depth and Quality and not in the meanings of the ancient technology and solutions that was ok before 15 years but are unacceptable with today's standards...
Ps. From your writings i can imagine that you are a fan of "the Inquisidor". Many text, ansient technology, no voice etc.
Back to top
KGen




Posts: 1082

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 12:49    Post subject:
griniaris wrote:
Everybody says that voise over is a bud think is a whacker



griniaris wrote:
What's your IQ' level ?
80 or less , at least that I can guess from your writings...




Oh, the irony


i7 6700k @ 4.4 GHZ, 2060s, 16 GB RAM, SSD, Windows 10x64.
Back to top
Clevesa




Posts: 3702

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 13:07    Post subject:
griniaris wrote:
KGen wrote:
griniaris wrote:

Every modern RPG that respects itself, have acceptable at least, voice cover.


You lost me there. The whole notion of this KS is to create a role playing game unlike the games we get today but something in the vein of old classics.
I won't go into comparing RPGs today and yesteryear but god help you if you mean Mass Effect or Dragon Age 2 as examples. Laughing

In any case you miss the point entirely. It's not about the size of the VO files that are a problem.


What's your IQ' level ?
80 or less , at least that I can guess from your writings...
Who speaks for bul..t games like Mass Effect or Dragon Age 2? Not me of course.
I speak for games like "The Witcher" and Deus ex and maybe partially Dragon Age 1.
They are voiced and have a development circle of 3 years at least.
Not 18 months and budget technology and so...
We want games, Like BG and P.T. in the meaning of depth and Quality and not in the meanings of the ancient technology and solutions that was ok before 15 years but are unacceptable with today's standards...
Ps. From your writings i can imagine that you are a fan of "the Inquisidor". Many text, ansient technology, no voice etc.


Why do you immediately go to personal lines? It seems it is you who lack the IQ. Instead of continuing a respectable discussion you had to spoil it by turning into a total idiot.
First of all, your point about The Witcher and Dues Ex is not valid at all, do you have any idea what budget these games worked with? The Witcher had a budget of 8 mil, so of course they could afford VO. Obsidian has less by 4 times. VO are over rated, yes they add to the game and it is indisputable more engrossing but a game can be still awesome without them.
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 13:16    Post subject:
KGen wrote:
griniaris wrote:
Everybody says that voise over is a bud think is a whacker



griniaris wrote:
What's your IQ' level ?
80 or less , at least that I can guess from your writings...




Oh, the irony

Probably, your sense of humor and the notion of meta modern type of writing Rolling Eyes , does not exist,.
It's ok, don't worry. It's typical in persons with low intelligence and low self-esteem Failed Troll .
Back to top
KGen




Posts: 1082

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 13:28    Post subject:
Clevesa wrote:
Why do you immediately go to personal lines? It seems it is you who lack the IQ. Instead of continuing a respectable discussion you had to spoil it by turning into a total idiot.First of all, your point about The Witcher and Dues Ex is not valid at all, do you have any idea what budget these games worked with? The Witcher had a budget of 8 mil, so of course they could afford VO. Obsidian has less by 4 times. VO are over rated, yes they add to the game and it is indisputable more engrossing but a game can be still awesome without them.


People talking out of their asses for the sake of looking cool on the internet is not new.

In any case, beyond comparing budgets, it makes more sense to compare the dialogue length. Witcher had awesome plot, but dialogue length wise it's not close to BG and P:T games. Since long dialogues take proportionally longer time to record, it means such dialogues will have to be finalized earlier in the development and frozen. This kind of constriction means the dialogues (unlike the budgets) tend to shrink considerably. The way they propose to do it makes sense and is similar to P:T - only some lines of dialogue will be voiced over to add atmosphere, but without hurting those long dialogue trees we like Smile


i7 6700k @ 4.4 GHZ, 2060s, 16 GB RAM, SSD, Windows 10x64.
Back to top
fable2




Posts: 6081

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 13:30    Post subject:
well they don't have to hire a lot of unique voices , look at skyrim for example , they got like five dudes doing all the voice work Laughing , it all comes down to the writing and how the actors would deliver the lines.
Back to top
tet666




Posts: 5096

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 13:44    Post subject:
Yeah but maybe thats rly not that what the audience wants from this project , it was specifically stated that this would be a game in the vein of the old IE Games, and thats exactly what i wanted. There are enough fully voiced (Action) RPGs for you guys to enjoy if this project is to oldschool for your tastes .
Back to top
fable2




Posts: 6081

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 13:50    Post subject:
how the fuck does having VO has anything to do with old school or not? back then most of them didn't have VO by choice, i am not saying they should cut the amount of text or words just to fit it, but they should at least do a goooooood bit of them.
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 14:06    Post subject:
Clevesa wrote:
griniaris wrote:
KGen wrote:


You lost me there. The whole notion of this KS is to create a role playing game unlike the games we get today but something in the vein of old classics.
I won't go into comparing RPGs today and yesteryear but god help you if you mean Mass Effect or Dragon Age 2 as examples. Laughing

In any case you miss the point entirely. It's not about the size of the VO files that are a problem.


What's your IQ' level ?
80 or less , at least that I can guess from your writings...
Who speaks for bul..t games like Mass Effect or Dragon Age 2? Not me of course.
I speak for games like "The Witcher" and Deus ex and maybe partially Dragon Age 1.
They are voiced and have a development circle of 3 years at least.
Not 18 months and budget technology and so...
We want games, Like BG and P.T. in the meaning of depth and Quality and not in the meanings of the ancient technology and solutions that was ok before 15 years but are unacceptable with today's standards...
Ps. From your writings i can imagine that you are a fan of "the Inquisidor". Many text, ansient technology, no voice etc.


Why do you immediately go to personal lines? It seems it is you who lack the IQ. Instead of continuing a respectable discussion you had to spoil it by turning into a total idiot.
First of all, your point about The Witcher and Dues Ex is not valid at all, do you have any idea what budget these games worked with? The Witcher had a budget of 8 mil, so of course they could afford VO. Obsidian has less by 4 times. VO are over rated, yes they add to the game and it is indisputable more engrossing but a game can be still awesome without them.

First, it wasn't me that use aggressive tone first. I just answer, in the same style, in arrogant remarks.
In the point now, they have a good sum to begin with. If they have to find more recourses, it's their responsibility, but i suspect that if they had had more tangible samples to present in this point of development, they can convince more people, eclectic people, that pays only what worth their money.
In the beginning of their kick start, after their clever promotion, they collect money very fast and if they could ride the tide, they maybe collect double of their today's sum...
Back to top
KGen




Posts: 1082

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 14:18    Post subject:
fable2 wrote:
how the fuck does having VO has anything to do with old school or not? back then most of them didn't have VO by choice, i am not saying they should cut the amount of text or words just to fit it, but they should at least do a goooooood bit of them.


The question is, if they did hire a limited number of actors to make the voice overs, would you consider it as an important addition to the game? When having to choose between compromising the immersion by cutting on the VO or the gameplay (by shifting budget from new quests, areas, characters and so on), I think most would go with the former.

In any case, they were very blatant from the start what kind of game they are making and what kind of players they cater for - old school rpg fans who enjoyed the IE games. I believe those kind of players will strongly appose to the notion of full VO for the game. It's not something they care about and no matter what budget you have they would rather have the money invested into other areas.


i7 6700k @ 4.4 GHZ, 2060s, 16 GB RAM, SSD, Windows 10x64.
Back to top
JackQ
Non-expret in Derps lagunge



Posts: 14527
Location: Kibbutznik, Israel
PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 15:05    Post subject:
Finally 2M,hope it will be doubled when kickstarter end


"Fuck Denuvo"

Your personal opinions != the rest of the forum
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Wed, 26th Sep 2012 15:23    Post subject:
JackQ wrote:
Finally 2M,hope it will be doubled when kickstarter end

2.5M is their best option today.
But if they were better prepared, it could be 4.5M or 5M.
Back to top
Page 15 of 114 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - PC Games Arena Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 14, 15, 16 ... 112, 113, 114  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group