Baldur's Gate 1/2
Page 28 of 64 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 27, 28, 29 ... 62, 63, 64  Next
VGAdeadcafe




Posts: 22230
Location: ★ ಠ_ಠ ★
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 21:24    Post subject:
locke89 wrote:
"With regards to the background art and character art, we are limited in what we can do from a purely graphical context as the original art assets were lost."

I can read, genius, but I'm wondering why they're lazy and don't do the 3d models and animations from scratch.
Back to top
Guyver




Posts: 2221
Location: Bunga-Bun... err Italy.
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 22:10    Post subject:
wasnt supposed to get out august 10th? what happened?


Back to top
beyond1




Posts: 658

PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 22:14    Post subject:
snip


Last edited by beyond1 on Tue, 29th Jul 2025 17:48; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Kanint




Posts: 2356

PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 22:29    Post subject:
VGAdeadcafe wrote:
locke89 wrote:
"With regards to the background art and character art, we are limited in what we can do from a purely graphical context as the original art assets were lost."

I can read, genius, but I'm wondering why they're lazy and don't do the 3d models and animations from scratch.

If they start remaking the game from scratch, it's gonna start requiring the same funding it would take to make a full game from scratch. This means the price of the game goes up and at this point, you may as well just make a new game.

Not having the original art assets doesn't mean they can't make improvements. They rebuilt the renderer and made the changes listed on the previous page (new way to filter the scene with OGL2ES, Catmull-Rom Bicubic filtering, Flipbook animation transparency and Alpha blending).

They'll be replacing the cinematics tho. Not much that can be done there, too low resolution.
Guyver wrote:
wasnt supposed to get out august 10th? what happened?

I don't think it was ever announced for August 10th. Releasing in 9 days.
Back to top
VGAdeadcafe




Posts: 22230
Location: ★ ಠ_ಠ ★
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 22:35    Post subject:
Redoing some simple 3d models (to be seen from a static isometric view) and their animations isn't the same as remaking BG2 from scratch ...

And they replaced the cinematics with animated ones, so lowbudget Laughing
Back to top
Clevesa




Posts: 3702

PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 23:05    Post subject:
VGAdeadcafe wrote:
Redoing some simple 3d models (to be seen from a static isometric view) and their animations isn't the same as remaking BG2 from scratch ...

And they replaced the cinematics with animated ones, so lowbudget Laughing


There are shitload of characters and animations to do,BG2 is huge. I guess they wanted to shorten the dev cycle.
Back to top
Kanint




Posts: 2356

PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 23:26    Post subject:
VGAdeadcafe wrote:
Redoing some simple 3d models (to be seen from a static isometric view) and their animations isn't the same as remaking BG2 from scratch ...

I didn't say it would be equivalent to a complete remake from scratch either. I'm saying it adds up to what they're already doing :
- Cut away at 2/3 of the source code.
- Replaced the graphic engine.
- Replaced the audio engine.
- Fixed the multiplayer.
- Fixed the threading model.

Adding "remake the models and animations of all (or most) of the characters in the game" would be one of the most expensive part of the project. Possibly the big one.
It WOULD considerably drive up the price of the game and if they had the funding to do this, they could simply make a new (smaller) game on their own.
(Which is actually what I think they should have done, to best honest. People are extremely critical when it comes to revisiting old classics.)
Back to top
Guyver




Posts: 2221
Location: Bunga-Bun... err Italy.
PostPosted: Sun, 9th Sep 2012 23:33    Post subject:
beyond1 wrote:
Guyver wrote:
wasnt supposed to get out august 10th? what happened?


Just download the resolution fix mod for the original BG and you've got your BG EE.

it crashes on my pc if i check/identify a magic item. Sad


Back to top
VGAdeadcafe




Posts: 22230
Location: ★ ಠ_ಠ ★
PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 00:48    Post subject:
"Replaced gfx engine" ? Well, if the asssets are the same, there's no improvement for the end user, besides resolution/widescreen fixes.

http://baldursgate.com/enhancements.en.html

Epic whine in spoiler Laughing Laughing
 Spoiler:
 


0fg = 0 fucks given
Back to top
Kanint




Posts: 2356

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 01:20    Post subject:
VGAdeadcafe wrote:
"Replaced gfx engine" ? Well, if the asssets are the same, there's no improvement for the end user, besides resolution/widescreen fixes.

You only have to look a few posts earlier to see various improvements listed =/.

Oh well. Epic whine? 0fg Wink
(That's just for fun, you're unimpressed by the game and that's fine.)
Back to top
DCB




Posts: 5410

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 03:45    Post subject:
VGAdeadcafe wrote:
so lowbudget Laughing

Of course. What sort of quick cash grab would it be if they had to outlay a lot of money?
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29452

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 03:50    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Tue, 5th Oct 2021 03:58; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
VGAdeadcafe




Posts: 22230
Location: ★ ಠ_ಠ ★
PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 05:07    Post subject:
Yep, human models are very few, they could improve those.

Also, lol at bullshit changes like filters, "fixed" MP, "fixed" threading model (wtf?), code refactoring bullshit.

What BG2 needed for an enhanced version is improved assets where possible based on the original ones (art, models, videos), add new NPC voice overs, add some cutscenes in pivotal points, add a whole new expansion and new recruitable NPCs with unique quests.

But you need to invest some money and talent for that, instead of sitting on a dildo all day while some noob fresh off of college adds touchscreen support on the most epic PC RPG ever.
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 09:01    Post subject:
The easiest way to improve the game is the FULL voice coverage.
Did they done that?
Back to top
tet666




Posts: 5096

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 09:11    Post subject:
Yeah every game needs full voiceovers because fuckers nowadays are too lazy to read...
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 09:40    Post subject:
tet666 wrote:
Yeah every game needs full voiceovers because fuckers nowadays are too lazy to read...

Don't be a retard please, if you can of course Wink
Voice over is essential for the immersion and ambience in any game. Without Minsk's "Go for the eye booo" and so.., BG would be the same?
It will be very good if we could hear all the excellent dialogs of the game with good voice acting and I could Pay for that...
Back to top
peter980




Posts: 1977

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 09:53    Post subject:
griniaris wrote:
The easiest way to improve the game is the FULL voice coverage.
Did they done that?


I doubt it, voices are expensive.

In fact, so much that many modern RPGs dialog systems suffer from "too little dialog choices", due to that.

And no voices is much better then poor voiceovers.
Back to top
Kanint




Posts: 2356

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 10:15    Post subject:
griniaris wrote:
tet666 wrote:
Yeah every game needs full voiceovers because fuckers nowadays are too lazy to read...

Don't be a retard please, if you can of course Wink
Voice over is essential for the immersion and ambience in any game. Without Minsk's "Go for the eye booo" and so.., BG would be the same?
It will be very good if we could hear all the excellent dialogs of the game with good voice acting and I could Pay for that...

New content is voiced (partial coverage) but they're not recording additional lines (or replacing previous ones) for old characters.
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 11:06    Post subject:
peter980 wrote:
griniaris wrote:
The easiest way to improve the game is the FULL voice coverage.
Did they done that?


I doubt it, voices are expensive.

In fact, so much that many modern RPGs dialog systems suffer from "too little dialog choices", due to that.

And no voices is much better then poor voiceovers.

I partially only agree with you. Even modest voice over is better than silence.
And why voice are so expensive? So many Actors are semi unemployed. We aren't in need for Julia Robert's voice to be happy...
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29452

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 11:18    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Tue, 5th Oct 2021 03:58; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Mister_s




Posts: 19862

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 11:47    Post subject:
I would not like the idea of VO, while it is great it killed extensive story-telling. There's too much text in this game for such a feat.

I still do not understand why improving character models and such would be so hard (this is not some "doing it in our free time" mod group as I understand), but it might be my technical ignorance concerning game development.
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14941
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 12:02    Post subject:
Improving all the character models would be a ton of work.. it's hundreds of thousands of animations, that alone would probably take a year or more for this small team. There's a reason why animations looks they way they do in those old 2D RPG's Wink we think they suck, but wow, it's an absolutely massive project to create them, it's one of the really big advantages of 3D engines.
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29452

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 12:03    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Tue, 5th Oct 2021 03:58; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14941
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 12:07    Post subject:
Exactly what is that you don't understand? If you need a source i can give you one:

http://www.sorcerers.net/Games/BG2/bg2faq.php

Q: How many frames of animation are there in the game?
A: : At last count there were roughly 108,420 frames of character and monster animations rendered for Baldur's Gate at BioWare for your viewing pleasure. We are adding 171,000 more frames for BGII:SoA. This does not include things like animated water, waving flags or other animated objects of any kind.
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29452

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 12:10    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Tue, 5th Oct 2021 03:58; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
vurt




Posts: 14941
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 12:16    Post subject:
Didn't say it was hard, you're right it would take a lot of time. Not only would they need to do animations, but they would also have to create new character models and everything that involves, including new weapons etc. It's not exactly just a few months of work if you want to do something that is exceptionally better than the original animations and graphics. And again, they don't have a ton of people.

And ofcourse they do it frame by frame, never said it couldnt be automated.
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29452

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 12:20    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Tue, 5th Oct 2021 03:58; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
griniaris
Banned



Posts: 70

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 13:19    Post subject:
Mister_s wrote:
I would not like the idea of VO, while it is great it killed extensive story-telling. There's too much text in this game for such a feat.

I still do not understand why improving character models and such would be so hard (this is not some "doing it in our free time" mod group as I understand), but it might be my technical ignorance concerning game development.

Pardon me?
How exactly V.O. kills extensive story-telling? It's illogical. The story is better preserved when narrative by a fine voice.
Anyway, animations and so, maybe wasn't economically efficient to be remade but replaying BG could be really a better experience, if they were added voice in the extensive unvoiced texts the game have.
But i think they dont care realy for the PC version but only for the tablets etc...
Back to top
DCB




Posts: 5410

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 14:14    Post subject:
It kills it because you cannot record full VO for a game the size of BG2. It is simply not economically feasible. Even game developers themselves freely admit this is the case. Text is cheap, VO is not.
Back to top
Mister_s




Posts: 19862

PostPosted: Mon, 10th Sep 2012 14:22    Post subject:
Try telling planescape torment's story with full voice over. I like VO, but it did lead to condensation of narrative since no studio can VO hours upon hours.
Back to top
Page 28 of 64 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - PC Games Arena Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 27, 28, 29 ... 62, 63, 64  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group