Diablo 3
Page 288 of 512 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 287, 288, 289 ... 510, 511, 512  Next
Ankh




Posts: 23605
Location: Trelleborg
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:29    Post subject:
BearishSun wrote:
It's an MMO, whether they classify it as such or not. In any case it's an ONLINE game. Diablo 3 singleplayer should not be an online game, because its SINGLEPLAYER.

I understand their reasoning for doing it, both to prevent cheaters and as a form of DRM, but they could have easily included an option for non-battlenet characters for singleplayer and LAN play.


MASSIVE multiplayer doesnt really feel right in diablo 3 though..


shitloads of new stuff in my pc. Cant keep track of it all.
Back to top
BearishSun




Posts: 4484

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:30    Post subject:
I was referring to guild wars ^^
Back to top
hailey




Posts: 866

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:31    Post subject:
GW2 you play with hundreds of people at the same time. It's an MMO.

D3 match making puts you with 1 other person max. It's a glorified co-op game.

They forced everyone online in D3 out of their own greed to have everyone on the AH and the system can't handle it. People have a legit reason to complain whether or not you think D3 singleplayer would be worth playing or not because the system isn't working well. For the record a huge number of the 14 million people who bought D2 didn't go online with it. How is giving your customer the choice such a huge problem to you valiant Blizzard defenders? Hell having those people who don't want to put up with the issues and just play the game right now in SP would alleviate so many of the server problems. By not allowing them they bring this on themselves. And you defend it lol. As if someone can't play SP in the interim and then start over online once the server issues are fixed.

Personally I would rather working servers over singleplayer. It's been 5 days now and they still suck.

Above all I'd rather get my $60 back though cause the game is a god-awful bore even if you can get online


Last edited by hailey on Sun, 20th May 2012 15:33; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Ankh




Posts: 23605
Location: Trelleborg
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:32    Post subject:
BearishSun wrote:
I was referring to guild wars ^^


Ahh yes - sorry, thought you ment diablo


shitloads of new stuff in my pc. Cant keep track of it all.
Back to top
Ankh




Posts: 23605
Location: Trelleborg
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:33    Post subject:
hailey wrote:

D3 match making puts you with 1 other person max. It's a glorified co-op game.


Perhaps match making - but I know that you can play more than 2 in a party.


shitloads of new stuff in my pc. Cant keep track of it all.
Back to top
tet666




Posts: 5096

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:33    Post subject:
Tbh Diablo would have been fine with an offline single player mode like d2, they only didnt do that because offline players wouldnt use the real money ah and thats all Activision/Blizz cares about, they designed the whole game around it removed everything besides loot to make your char unique.


Last edited by tet666 on Sun, 20th May 2012 15:35; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
tolanri




Posts: 3589

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:33    Post subject:
sausje wrote:
Just pick a chapter just before him Wink


Yeah but that way I won't have as high chance to get more loot from rares until I get it to 5 stacks again. So either way I'm screwed Very Happy
Back to top
hailey




Posts: 866

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:34    Post subject:
Ankh wrote:
hailey wrote:

D3 match making puts you with 1 other person max. It's a glorified co-op game.


Perhaps match making - but I know that you can play more than 2 in a party.


Yes. a whopping 4. Massive lol wut

Most people play with 1, and don't really care for the AH. But they must never be allowed to do it offline, they would miss the MMO experience!!! Thank god they have Blizz and their legion of fanboys to protect them from themselves


Last edited by hailey on Sun, 20th May 2012 15:36; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:36    Post subject:
tolanri wrote:
sausje wrote:
Just pick a chapter just before him Wink


Yeah but that way I won't have as high chance to get more loot from rares until I get it to 5 stacks again. So either way I'm screwed Very Happy


Yea, but you still have 5 stacks for Diablo then Razz


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
tolanri




Posts: 3589

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:36    Post subject:
hailey wrote:
Yes. a whopping 4. Massive lol wut

Most people play with 1, and don't really care for the AH. But they must never be allowed to do it offline, they would miss the MMO experience!!! Thank god they have Blizz and their legion of fanboys to protect them from themselves


Yes, hence why it's so similar to GW1. Instead of character selection with AH, chat and stuff you were in towns, and adventured with at most 12 players (usually max 8 ).
Back to top
hailey




Posts: 866

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:41    Post subject:
Yes but GW is a pvp game at its core. Even if the coop (that goes to 12 players, 3 times more than d3) could be done offline, the entire game revolves around player vs player. PVP in D3 is such an afterthought they removed it lol

It's comparing apples to oranges
Back to top
MAD_MAX333
Moderator



Posts: 7020
Location: Toronto, Canada...eh
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:43    Post subject:
They should have made a way to check and purchase stuff on the AH by simply logging into ur battlenet account online.
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:44    Post subject:
MAD_MAX333 wrote:
They should have made a way to check and purchase stuff on the AH by simply logging into ur battlenet account online.


How do you prevent people from hacking items then?


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
hailey




Posts: 866

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:44    Post subject:
They have the mobile AH for WoW, maybe they'll do that. But I think it cost an monthly fee to use. Maybe they'll come out with Call of Diablo Elite service
Back to top
Pl@tinum




Posts: 1036

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:47    Post subject:
tet666 wrote:
Tbh Diablo would have been fine with an offline single player mode like d2, they only didnt do that because offline players wouldnt use the real money ah and thats all Activision/Blizz cares about, they designed the whole game around it removed everything besides loot to make your char unique.


You're wrong. They don't want offline singleplayer 'cause of piracy and hacking. If the code was not in their servers the AH would be fulls of dupes in a week, ruining the game's economy.

"removed everything besides loot to make your char unique" ---- Are we still talking about diablo? 'cause i really can't remember unique chars in the series.
Back to top
JBeckman
VIP Member



Posts: 35866
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:52    Post subject:
Would that even work?

Remove achievements, remove auction house function and keep player saves and data on the client side for SP mode (Or open co-op / LAN play.), for Battle.net / online mode keep all data server side as currently and with no way to transfer in between those modes and thus no way to modify data as it's fully server side this time.
(I think a majority of the data was still on the client but closed in Diablo 2 was apparently quite OK.)

EDIT: It would allow piracy though but that's unavoidable.
Back to top
cyclonefr




Posts: 7065

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:54    Post subject:
@Pl@tinum : who said Blizzard would need to add the AH code in the client side ? They could put a single player mode without any AH (obviously, AH in single player would be plain dumb). This excuse about cheaters is really funny...

Remember Diablo 2 characters were stored in client side only for Open Battte.net and SP, not for Closed Battle.net. Closed Battle.net didn't prevent cheaters, and the same will happen with this game, people always find tricks.

EDIT : JBeckman beat me.
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:57    Post subject:
JBeckman wrote:
Would that even work?

Remove achievements, remove auction house function and keep player saves and data on the client side for SP mode (Or open co-op / LAN play.), for Battle.net / online mode keep all data server side as currently and with no way to transfer in between those modes and thus no way to modify data as it's fully server side this time.
(I think a majority of the data was still on the client but closed in Diablo 2 was apparently quite OK.)

EDIT: It would allow piracy though but that's unavoidable.


In Diablo 2, most hacks, dupes, weirdo items, came mostly from D2 singleplayer/open bnet chars. People found a way to move items from SP chars into Closed Bnet (server side chars).

So, no.
Back to top
JBeckman
VIP Member



Posts: 35866
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 15:58    Post subject:
Yes but if you kept it all server side that would be impossible here. Smile
(No local file for the stash, no files for character data or anything.)6

EDIT: Could even use two different formats or other code to prevent such from happening, there's a number of solutions.

You can still hack certain data though and that would be easier with the core files on the local client side available, there are speed trainers and map trainers already for the game from what I know.

(Encryption could also work for save files and many other techniques so it can be eliminated if they should want to.)


Last edited by JBeckman on Sun, 20th May 2012 16:01; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:01    Post subject:
well, the moment you allow client side SP, all the info is there. Its simply a matter of time to figure out how to use the information.
Back to top
JBeckman
VIP Member



Posts: 35866
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:03    Post subject:
But you can't upload said data to the server and with Warden and other anti cheat advances it would be a instant account ban wouldn't it?

I'm not claiming to know how this works or anything but as I see it there's not much of a problem if they would have wanted (they don't want to.) to have this method of play.

That said security is a concern what with the real money auction house, if that's compromised in some way Blizzard would have a really big problem.
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:05    Post subject:
thats exactly what happend in Diablo 2.

They figured out how to "falsify" the packets send from client to server, using info gathered from Singleplayer chars.

add :

items like this :



made with editors in SP and then transfered into closed bnet somehow using modified packets (or something, im not a specialist in that sort of things hehe)
Back to top
JBeckman
VIP Member



Posts: 35866
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:08    Post subject:
Then I stand corrected, I forgot about packet sniffing and other means to "attack" or bug the server in some way.
(Or server cluster in this case I guess, Blizzard would likely go after such attempts via legal means though but I'm just guessing.)

Though wouldn't some of this happen when they (if they but it was done for the beta.) work on a client side emulator of the database or what that server does?
(Figuring out how the server works and what it sends and what the data it sends does for example, again I'm far from good at this sort of thing but it seems plausible though as it is a online game people will try to hack and gain advantages, that earlier gold selling announcement for example or the current cheats for the map and other data that can be affected.)
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:10    Post subject:
i guess eventually it might be possible, hopefully not. But it should at least keep it down, i.e. make it less likely.


Time will tell hehe.
Back to top
pakko




Posts: 263
Location: Pizzaland
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:21    Post subject:
Server EU is down.....................
Back to top
dog-god




Posts: 524

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:21    Post subject:
Im be surprised if DoS attacking the servers doesn't happen soon when more technical people get pissed of at not being able to play.


As for what Sin317 said about people being able to falsify packets back to the servers previously, given that expertise wont these same guys just get info from the packets being sent to the client as well as what info is being sent from the client to the server this time to start a hacking spree.
Back to top
Sin317
Banned



Posts: 24318
Location: Geneva
PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:24    Post subject:
its a bit more complicated i guess.

Back then, in D2, those dupes and hacked items etc were moved to Closed Bnet on whole characters from SP.

Its not simply sending a couple packets and voila. You'd need the whole info etc about stored characters or something.
Back to top
BearishSun




Posts: 4484

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:26    Post subject:
If you could falsify items that was bad server programming on blizzards end. Even if hackers have complete server code, and the server was decently made, it would not be possible to create items.

Technically they could make the server only receive mouse input packets (mouse coordinates and presses) making the client completely dumb. Although they probably didn't go to those lengths it's an example of the protection they can make. There is no way to inject data by falsifying those packets now is there Wink


Last edited by BearishSun on Sun, 20th May 2012 16:26; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
tolanri




Posts: 3589

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:26    Post subject:
dog-god wrote:
Im be surprised if DoS attacking the servers doesn't happen soon when more technical people get pissed of at not being able to play.


I'm "more technical" (aka I know of script kiddies tools most people use for DDoS), but I would never do it. What would one gain from it? ESPECIALLY if they are pissed that they cannot play. Do people gain some satisfaction from disrupting someone else's service? I consider DDoS attacks just new age vandalism.

If somebody wants to vent their rage on the internet, just go troll on official forums. It doesn't do much harm that way Smile


Intel Core i7 6700K @ 4.6 GHz | Asus Z170 Pro Gaming | Corsair Vengenace LPX 16GB DDR4 3200 MHz | MSI GeForce GTX 1080 FE | Samsung 850 EVO 500 GB + 250 GB | EVGA SuperNOVA 750 G2 | Fractal Design Define R5 | Noctua NH-D14
Back to top
Pl@tinum




Posts: 1036

PostPosted: Sun, 20th May 2012 16:30    Post subject:
cyclonefr wrote:
@Pl@tinum : who said Blizzard would need to add the AH code in the client side ? They could put a single player mode without any AH (obviously, AH in single player would be plain dumb). This excuse about cheaters is really funny...

Remember Diablo 2 characters were stored in client side only for Open Battte.net and SP, not for Closed Battle.net. Closed Battle.net didn't prevent cheaters, and the same will happen with this game, people always find tricks.

EDIT : JBeckman beat me.


Are you really mentioning Diablo 2, 'cause Diablo 2 offline/online systems are the reason why Diablo 3 is online only. It was a dupe fest.

I agree with you on the last bit though, people really always find ways, but this time there's no red carpet, and hopefully it can be minimized.
Back to top
Page 288 of 512 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - PC Games Arena Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3 ... 287, 288, 289 ... 510, 511, 512  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group