Onlive (The end of PC gaming as we know it)
Page 3 of 15 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4 ... 13, 14, 15  Next
crossmr




Posts: 2966
Location: United Kingdom
PostPosted: Fri, 4th Sep 2009 15:38    Post subject:
They will never overcome ping problems with this generation of technology. Only in korea can you regularly see 10 ms pings to servers outside your network and even that isn't completely consistent.

Most people just don't have the connection to handle this.

They want to stop piracy then they need to copy Korea. There is no piracy with Korean games, because they're all free.

They need to work on real business models with microtransactions for non-game effecting stuff and roll those out.

EA has shown they have zero skill at it. Since BF heroes has crashed and burned I'm getting weekly emails with surveys saying "Why won't you come back??? what if we broke the MT code and started offering game changing items for money, would you come back then? what if we sent an intern to come to your house and massage your feet while you played? How about then?"


intel ultra 7 265k, 64gb ram, 3070
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Fri, 4th Sep 2009 15:41    Post subject:
Hahaha!

Man, I hadn't thought of BF-Zeroes for months now. I waited so anxiously for that game, but when it finally came out .. it was massively disappointing.

As far as Korean MMOs go? I hate you all. I hate you out of pure envy, as there's always some MMOs only available in Korea that look great fun! (I especially hate you for having Hellgate London Sad)
Back to top
Glottis
Banned



Posts: 6313

PostPosted: Fri, 4th Sep 2009 15:42    Post subject:
crossmr wrote:
Only in korea can you regularly see 10 ms pings to servers outside your network and even that isn't completely consistent.

Are you kidding me? In Europe we have 10ms TO OTHER COUNTRIES. From one end of Europe to another is like 20-30ms.


C2D E6750 @ 3.2Ghz, 4GB 800MHz DDR2 4-4-4-12, GeForce GTX 260 c216 OC 896MB, 3.2TB, Windows 7 Ultimate x64

Xbox 360 Elite, PS2 Slim, Xbox
Back to top
crossmr




Posts: 2966
Location: United Kingdom
PostPosted: Sat, 5th Sep 2009 16:13    Post subject:
Glottis wrote:
crossmr wrote:
Only in korea can you regularly see 10 ms pings to servers outside your network and even that isn't completely consistent.

Are you kidding me? In Europe we have 10ms TO OTHER COUNTRIES. From one end of Europe to another is like 20-30ms.


Is everyone getting that? It certainly isn't remotely true in North America. When I was in North America, even on the fastest connections I could get, you'd jump to 20 or 30 as soon as you left your front door.

and if europe was that good, why would everyone be holding up Korea as the be all and end all of awesome internet? Surely more western writers would be much more familiar with europe than Korea.
Back to top
Parallax_
VIP Member



Posts: 6422
Location: Norway
PostPosted: Sat, 5th Sep 2009 16:22    Post subject:
Glottis wrote:
Are you kidding me? In Europe we have 10ms TO OTHER COUNTRIES. From one end of Europe to another is like 20-30ms.

You are exagerrating, I take it. Depending on your network setup, your ISP, various routes, as well as external routing between AS', it can take you anywhere from 20MS to 70MS for the traffic to reach another country. That is not counting if you have to traverse several AS'. If traffic has to travel over the atlantic, you would have to go over 100MS, unless you are VERY lucky.

No doubt this technology will flop, because latency will kill it. You have to send full audio and video frames - and for movies that is fine, but for local gaming it's instakill because of the latency.


Upcoming PC games 2009 and onwards
Bravery is not a function of firepower.
Back to top
Glottis
Banned



Posts: 6313

PostPosted: Sat, 5th Sep 2009 16:29    Post subject:
crossmr wrote:
Glottis wrote:
crossmr wrote:
Only in korea can you regularly see 10 ms pings to servers outside your network and even that isn't completely consistent.

Are you kidding me? In Europe we have 10ms TO OTHER COUNTRIES. From one end of Europe to another is like 20-30ms.


Is everyone getting that? It certainly isn't remotely true in North America. When I was in North America, even on the fastest connections I could get, you'd jump to 20 or 30 as soon as you left your front door.

and if europe was that good, why would everyone be holding up Korea as the be all and end all of awesome internet? Surely more western writers would be much more familiar with europe than Korea.

You are misinformed. http://www.speedtest.net/global.php
Check how many European countries are in that list. Europe has the best connections in the world and my country Lithuania is leading. 4th place and 1st place is better than Korea's 1st place and 15th place.

Also, afaik, Korea has horrible routing outside of Korea and in Europe that's not the case. We get good routing to entire world.


C2D E6750 @ 3.2Ghz, 4GB 800MHz DDR2 4-4-4-12, GeForce GTX 260 c216 OC 896MB, 3.2TB, Windows 7 Ultimate x64

Xbox 360 Elite, PS2 Slim, Xbox
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75741
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 11:37    Post subject:
Back to top
dezztroy




Posts: 6590
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 11:57    Post subject:
That actually looked pretty cool. Could be awesome if it really does work well.

Also, that demonstration had a slide that said used games cost made publishers lose as much money as they do from piracy. Huh.
Back to top
grapper




Posts: 877
Location: Nuked
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 12:20    Post subject:
Can't believe most people still deal with bandwith caps on regular Internet connections, I truly feel sorry for you. I also didn't expect a bunch of raging nerds to actually realize that this might be something for the future. Bandwith caps are a big problem to the service, I realize that. Hopefully as Internet "matures" and ISP's can't explain their idiotic caps with that they are stopping "high bandwith usage pirates", hopefully they disappear. There will be more and more streaming services including spotify, Voddler and now this in the future.

Who cares about the 1% nerd population that thinks this is shit. Look at the Wii as a good example for this.
Back to top
Ghworg




Posts: 926

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 12:33    Post subject:
grapper wrote:
Can't believe most people still deal with bandwith caps on regular Internet connections, I truly feel sorry for you. I also didn't expect a bunch of raging nerds to actually realize that this might be something for the future. Bandwith caps are a big problem to the service, I realize that. Hopefully as Internet "matures" and ISP's can't explain their idiotic caps with that they are stopping "high bandwith usage pirates", hopefully they disappear. There will be more and more streaming services including spotify, Voddler and now this in the future.

Who cares about the 1% nerd population that thinks this is shit. Look at the Wii as a good example for this.



Where do you get that 1% from?

I'm sure over 50% thinks this is shit.

And Wii has nothing to do with this crap.
Back to top
KeyserSoeze




Posts: 800

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 12:43    Post subject:
I think this is a good idea in theory but im skeptical about if today's hardware is sufficient.

About the ping issue, they must be able to give a ping of 40 or less, otherwise this will never work and i guess they know it, i cant see them releasing this if the ping would be 100+, they cant be that stupid... Smile
Back to top
grapper




Posts: 877
Location: Nuked
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 12:53    Post subject:
Ghworg wrote:
grapper wrote:
Can't believe most people still deal with bandwith caps on regular Internet connections, I truly feel sorry for you. I also didn't expect a bunch of raging nerds to actually realize that this might be something for the future. Bandwith caps are a big problem to the service, I realize that. Hopefully as Internet "matures" and ISP's can't explain their idiotic caps with that they are stopping "high bandwith usage pirates", hopefully they disappear. There will be more and more streaming services including spotify, Voddler and now this in the future.

Who cares about the 1% nerd population that thinks this is shit. Look at the Wii as a good example for this.



Where do you get that 1% from?

I'm sure over 50% thinks this is shit.

And Wii has nothing to do with this crap.

I did some extensive research that got me to the conclusion that exactly 1% thought it was shit.

No seriously, I am talking about the hardcore gamers, that are no longer the most important market, having to dismiss everything before they even try it. The worst conservatists out there. Rolling Eyes


Last edited by grapper on Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 12:56; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
dezztroy




Posts: 6590
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 12:54    Post subject:
If you watch the video, they say that the ping will always be under 80.
Back to top
Neon
VIP Member



Posts: 18941
Location: Poland
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 14:49    Post subject:
dezztroy wrote:
If you watch the video, they say that the ping will always be under 80.


If you listen to companies, you believe that 100 ms ping through LAN is "perfectly fine" Embarassed
Back to top
bishman82




Posts: 343

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 15:01    Post subject:
If they have enough server centres all over the place i could see it happening but it will have to work flawlessly 100% of the time or the whole service will be useless. My home connection is very reliable and i notice the occasional lag even on game servers local to me, it's hardly noticable because the game is running locally and it does a good job of hiding network problems, if that game was running on a server and streaming the video to me i would have a frozen screen or blocky compression artifacts, and now it will be affecting single player games as well.

The fact that they are promising things like <80 ping across networks they don't own or have ANY control over whatsoever is the main reason i wouldn't believe a thing they say.
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75741
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 15:07    Post subject:
Neon25 wrote:
If you listen to companies, you believe that 100 ms ping through LAN is "perfectly fine" Embarassed

Well, consider the target audience audience. That is where things come after all. Give that system to a noob causal console player, and he will probably not feel any problem at all (especially if you see that they are marketing their controller as part of the deal - a gamepad). No hardcore gamer would trade his high-end PC, built for twitch gaming, for a crap like this.
But I will say this, if this thing allows me to test demos of games for free without having to download them (i.e. see how crap they are without having to shift-delete in rage), then I might give it a try. Smile


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
Big_Gun




Posts: 3017
Location: My mother's womb originally. . .
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 15:09    Post subject:
grapper wrote:
and ISP's can't explain their idiotic caps with that they are stopping "high bandwith usage pirates"


Buddy of mine now works for an ISP.
He explained it like this:
His company actually buys their bandwidth through a 2nd company.
All of them do.
They pay x dollars for their bandwidth.
When their customer base starts using more bandwidth than they pay for to the 2nd company, it costs them money. So, the solution is to either raise the rates for everyone or impose a bandwidth limit and get rid of the minority that use the most.


1 stripe purple belt in JiuJitsu (good grief this takes FOREVER hahah)
Back to top
grapper




Posts: 877
Location: Nuked
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 15:18    Post subject:
Big_Gun wrote:
grapper wrote:
and ISP's can't explain their idiotic caps with that they are stopping "high bandwith usage pirates"


Buddy of mine now works for an ISP.
He explained it like this:
His company actually buys their bandwidth through a 2nd company.
All of them do.
They pay x dollars for their bandwidth.
When their customer base starts using more bandwidth than they pay for to the 2nd company, it costs them money. So, the solution is to either raise the rates for everyone or impose a bandwidth limit and get rid of the minority that use the most.

I know exactly how it works. And the solutions you are suggesting might be true for that particular ISP, but there are other ways of getting to the root of the problem. Such as looking at how IPS's like that are billed for access. Maybe there needs to be some governmental involvement? As much as I hate that usually in some areas it might be needed.

Anyway, capping Internet usage will without a doubt be a question of much debate as streaming services are becoming more and more common.

I also agree that latency might be a big problem. BUT - if you get the hardware for free or 50 bucks and access to the latest and greatest games. Then I think a LOT of people that are not as hardcore as most of the posters here can live with a ping in the 30-90 range. No problem at all. Most people won't notice it.
Back to top
EwarWoo1




Posts: 868

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:03    Post subject:
Big_Gun wrote:
grapper wrote:
and ISP's can't explain their idiotic caps with that they are stopping "high bandwith usage pirates"


Buddy of mine now works for an ISP.
He explained it like this:
His company actually buys their bandwidth through a 2nd company.
All of them do.
They pay x dollars for their bandwidth.
When their customer base starts using more bandwidth than they pay for to the 2nd company, it costs them money. So, the solution is to either raise the rates for everyone or impose a bandwidth limit and get rid of the minority that use the most.

Maybe different from country to country as it's definitely not that way over here.

If you're an ISP you don't buy data in that way, you buy bandwidth with no limits on it.

You then need to decide on a reasonable contention ratio to resell that bandwidth at a profit, once you also take off other costs.

If you allow unlimited usage you don't end up paying more, you do however end up with a higher contention ratio, slow internet and very unhappy customer's.
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:06    Post subject:
I can't believe people still think this is going to work Laughing It's not JUST about latency or bandwidth, it's about the whole package - playing a game with highest settings, getting a certain framerate, and then encoding ON THE FLY to transmit data back and forth and still keep it playable?

If it works, I'll eat my hat (and I LIKE my hat, I'd rather not eat it thankyouverymuch) but honestly? It's a pipe-dream, all of it.
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75741
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:07    Post subject:
It was actually demonstrated on the video, and works quite well. Smile I want pics of hat eating!


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:21    Post subject:



You disappoint me, mate. "We were playing MW2 on a LAN at 100ms and it was fine" Yeah, showing a demonstration of a game being hosted from a server in another room is *definitely* all the proof I need to know it's working Laughing
Back to top
Nui
VIP Member



Posts: 5720
Location: in a place with fluffy towels
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:30    Post subject:
i think iNatan would sell himself out for a minute if that means you'd have to eat a hat... so... why dont you just eat a hat ? Razz
there's an edit button for a reason durr hurr use it iNatan, use it!
Back to top
Big_Gun




Posts: 3017
Location: My mother's womb originally. . .
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:33    Post subject:
Well, i for one hope it does work.
I am tired of upgrading.
plus, developers wont have the excuse of having to develop for such a wide range of hardware any more.

As far as ISP's go, i dunno jack about the business. i only know what he told me. Not saying i agree with it or claiming i know a solution.
I do know that there is a new company coming into my neighborhood that is offering up to 100 mbps symmetrical fiber connection and it does not have any data limits on it.
Been seeing the trucks in here running the fiber. Supposedly will have service in about a month.


1 stripe purple belt in JiuJitsu (good grief this takes FOREVER hahah)
Back to top
proekaan
VIP Member



Posts: 3651
Location: Finland
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:48    Post subject:
And where do hardware manufacturers come in all this?
If cloud gaming is the future,then there is no need for GPU,CPU etc manufacturers...I don't see that as a good thing.

And I found it funny how the audience was gasping when the guy said you can watch other ppl playing.
I for one would hate to have spectators while playing a single player... :/


AMD Ryzen 9 7900X 4,7 GHz
Asrock X670E Steel Legend
G.Skill Trident Z5 32 GB DDR5 6400Mhz
Asus TUF RTX 4090 24 GB GDDR6X
NZXT Kraken Z73 RGB
Corsair HX1500i Platinum
NZXT H7 Flow
Back to top
Big_Gun




Posts: 3017
Location: My mother's womb originally. . .
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 16:54    Post subject:
Just watched some of the video (still watching it). i think this is some of the coolest shit ever. . . if it works.


1 stripe purple belt in JiuJitsu (good grief this takes FOREVER hahah)
Back to top
LeoNatan
☢ NFOHump Despot ☢



Posts: 75741
Location: Israel
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 17:11    Post subject:
@Sabin and Nui

In that demonstration people were actually playing. Like I said, this is aimed at casual people playing with a gamepad (read all kind of shit assists), so from that point of view, it works, and works well in the demonstration.
Damn right I want to see Sabin eat a hat.


My IMDb Ratings | Fix NFOHump Cookies | Hide Users / Threads | Embedded Content (Videos/GIFs/Twitter/Reddit) | The Derps Collection

“Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened.”
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 18:49    Post subject:
"It compresses the video in 1ms"

*sigh* And you believe this bullshit, mate? Honestly? Ah well, no video is ever going to convince me it "works" - I'll wait for the suckers to buy into it all and then hear their feedback. If it ever comes out Razz

As I've said before; I hope it DOES work. I really do. No more fucking about with super-expensive hardware updates, games just work and work well thanks to distributed computing, and it can even be plugged into a TV and ran from there. TRUE portable gaming. I'd rather pay $15/mo than $600-700 a YEAR in upgrades.

I just don't think (and neither do noted network experts) it's possible.




Oh and let's just throw this in here;

iNatan wrote:
Yeah, Sabin, stop acting like an ostrich, get on with the times! These new technologies really are amazing!!1

*Off to compress a Bluray with h265 so it fits in a diskette, then play Crysis on FX 5200 using DX15 with magic acceleration.*


 Spoiler:
 































.... and yes, the 45 minute demo DOES look great. I'm still sceptical though.
Back to top
banish




Posts: 858

PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 20:40    Post subject:
yeah i'm still sceptical and if it does work...i'm in no doubt about it(that if they bring it in my country)
Back to top
Xenthalon




Posts: 1722
Location: Germany
PostPosted: Sat, 2nd Jan 2010 20:47    Post subject:
This presentation changed my opinion tremendously. Especially if you play a relaxed game with a controller it sure does have it's benefits; however for competitive play I would still prefer a local installation.

Additionally I really want to know the quality impact of the compression they use. Because what purpose would Crysis on max quality serve if things look blurry.
Back to top
Page 3 of 15 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - PC Games Arena Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4 ... 13, 14, 15  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group