Need advice to buy a SATA HD
Page 1 of 1
Kommando




Posts: 4863
Location: Vinland
PostPosted: Mon, 7th Nov 2005 01:17    Post subject: Need advice to buy a SATA HD
Im about to buy a new computer and im confused about SATA's HD sine they different things on them.

Im looking at a W/DIGITAL 200G 7200RPM SATA-300 or a MAXTOR 200G 7200RPM SATA-150 16M

Is there a big difference between the 300 and 150 and why Maxtor have 16m and not teh W/D?
Back to top
Shoomy




Posts: 3

PostPosted: Mon, 7th Nov 2005 11:59    Post subject:
There are WDs with 16MB buffer...
they obviously cost more.

Diffrence between SATA-150 and SATA-300(SATA 2)
is that sata 2 is faster. twice the transfer rate.

And if your'e gonna buy sata 2 be sure to buy a mobo that supports one
Back to top
Steve-O 2004




Posts: 2851

PostPosted: Mon, 7th Nov 2005 19:44    Post subject:
so is SATA much better than IDE??


George W Bush -

'...more and more of our imports are coming from overseas.'
Back to top
Kommando




Posts: 4863
Location: Vinland
PostPosted: Mon, 7th Nov 2005 20:21    Post subject:
Steve-O 2004 wrote:
so is SATA much better than IDE??


Yes, the transfer rate of a SATA is 3gig/second
Back to top
pancake




Posts: 1091
Location: England
PostPosted: Mon, 7th Nov 2005 21:56    Post subject:
Kommando wrote:
Steve-O 2004 wrote:
so is SATA much better than IDE??


Yes, the transfer rate of a SATA is 3gig/second


i wish it was 3 gig a second ... try 57mb a second with a raptor you may get 65. with ide you may get 45 mb\s
Back to top
Steve-O 2004




Posts: 2851

PostPosted: Mon, 7th Nov 2005 22:45    Post subject:
so only realy about 12mb a sec faster?


George W Bush -

'...more and more of our imports are coming from overseas.'
Back to top
Kommando




Posts: 4863
Location: Vinland
PostPosted: Tue, 8th Nov 2005 01:05    Post subject:
Steve-O 2004 wrote:
so only realy about 12mb a sec faster?


Im pretty sure its way much faster than that..of course if you transfer SATA --> IDE it might go that slow, but SATA --> SATA should go at 3gig/second
Back to top
JumpyJim




Posts: 113
Location: Ecosse
PostPosted: Tue, 8th Nov 2005 02:20    Post subject:
I think your getting confused over the marketing hype for SATA. SATA 300 is also known as 3 gigabit. 300 megs times 8 gives you 2.4 gbits, sprinkle some magical fairy dust and it's 3 gigabits.

SATA supports up to 150 / 300 MB/s interface bandwidth, but that's the technologies interface throughput (much like PATA's 100/133 MB/s theoretical speed), in reality, your still stuck with PATA based technology, that is, hard drives still running at 7,200 rpm (exception being Raptor 10k drives). Sure there is the newish SATA native command queueing technologies (idea pinched from SCSI technology) which can boost performance by a teeny fraction (albeit using higher cpu usage), but your still stuck with drives based essentially on old technology.

So I'd say hotplugging, slightly faster MB/s transfers and significantly better cable management are the pluspoints that SATA drives have over PATA.

Think of PATA to SATA like that of AGP to PCI-E. For example the AGP 4/8x bus still isn't even saturated today when running the latest highest quality games, but yet we now have PCI-Express.

But those figures pancake mentioned, give or take a few MB/s are correct.


ZX81 fanboy.
Back to top
Page 1 of 1 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Hardware Zone
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group