Rate my junk
Page 1 of 2 Goto page 1, 2  Next
[mrt]
[Admin] Code Monkey



Posts: 1342

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 00:00    Post subject: Rate my junk
Hey wizz'zs

Here's a media-livingroom-tv-depot PC im throwing together and I could surely use your input,

Intel Core i3-2105 (HD3000 GPU)
Asus P8Z68-V LX
Kingston DDR3 1333 4GB (8 seems like an overkill, altho it might get shared with the GPU?)
WD5000AAKX (only decently priced HDD atm)
Antec Basiq 450W
Coolermaster Elite 360 case (cheap & horizontal & no uATX dwarfiness)
Sound card?

The main goal is that it should handle any HD playback without as much as a sneeze and the usual web/office crap. It would be nice if the thing wasn't too noisy. Anything i should watch out for? Antec PSU is 120mm equipped and usually pretty silent, only thing that might be squeeling is the stock intel cooler.

Also I've came across a bizzare rumor that the Z68 motherboards buzz alot due to the power chokes. High pitched sounds would surely make anyone around go mad. Anyone had any such experiences with them boards yet?

Suggestions for a good DVDRW drive are welcome too. I haven't got a clue which brand I should pick. If NEC was still around in its former glorry I'd certanly go with them. My 3520A is golden Smile

Been thinking of putting in a sound card too for better quality sound (it'll be hooked up to a AV receiver), I figured a Creative card would do good maybe X-Fi or an Asus Xonar. But I'm probably holding off on that one to see how the integrated thing fesses up, but I dont have high expectations of it anyway.

Thanks!


teey
Back to top
Nhiumewyn
Banned



Posts: 2705

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 00:03    Post subject:
EDIT: Nevermind..


Last edited by Nhiumewyn on Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 00:40; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
zipfero




Posts: 8938
Location: White Shaft
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 00:05    Post subject:
Can comment on the mobo as I have a z68 pro and I havent heard any noises so far..I use headphones a lot, though so I may have an advantage there but so far no sounds!

And to your topic title, its not the biggest I've seen but you use it very effectively!


8 out of 10 dentists prefer zipfero to competing brands(fraich3 and Mutantius)!
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 00:38    Post subject:
Donno if the GPU can handle full HD playback, my laptop (i3-2310m) has sometimes framedips under 60 fps with splash pro..


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
MinderMast




Posts: 6172

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 01:12    Post subject:
You shouldn't need a discrete sound card if you intend to use a receiver. The optimal choice for audio output would be over HDMI, which the integrated GPU provides already with full support of all the necessary audio formats.

Furthermore, there won't be any gains in terms of audio quality even if you do get the sound card, since your receiver will be doing all the audio processing. By using HDMI or S/PDIF connections you essentially bypass your sound card.

Never heard any weird noises on my Z68 board (it's from MSI though).
Back to top
outtanames




Posts: 1591

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 03:46    Post subject:
sausje wrote:
Donno if the GPU can handle full HD playback, my laptop (i3-2310m) has sometimes framedips under 60 fps with splash pro..


It's not the same. HD3000 should handle it no problems. That's why he didn't get a discrete GPU.
Back to top
Interinactive
VIP Member



Posts: 29459

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 03:59    Post subject:
⁢⁢


Last edited by Interinactive on Tue, 5th Oct 2021 04:32; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Mchart




Posts: 7314

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 09:34    Post subject:
Just get 8GB. It costs like maybe 10 bucks more for 2 4GB sticks instead of 2 2GB sticks.

Anyways, for a home theater PC I would wait for Ivy Bridge. The iGPU is getting a substantial upgrade with Ivy Bridge.
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 10:34    Post subject:
outtanames wrote:
sausje wrote:
Donno if the GPU can handle full HD playback, my laptop (i3-2310m) has sometimes framedips under 60 fps with splash pro..


It's not the same. HD3000 should handle it no problems. That's why he didn't get a discrete GPU.


Uhm yes, they are the same: i3-2310m and i3-2105
Both intel HD 3000, the other one just a little higher clockspeeds on the GPU.

He didn't mean a AMD card, because there is no HD3000 from AMD, there is the HD3000 SERIES, but no card itself called that way. Smile


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
Slizza




Posts: 2345
Location: Bulgaria
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 10:52    Post subject:
A blu ray movie @ 1080p is usually about 24fps is it not?


Corsair 750D :: 750W DPS-G:: Asus x370 PRO :: R7 1800X ::16gb DDR4 :: GTX 1070::525gb SSD::Coolermaster 240MM AIO::
Back to top
MinderMast




Posts: 6172

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 10:57    Post subject:
Well, those CPU+iGPU combos are designed with FullHD playback in mind. There shouldn't be any problems under normal circumstances. FullHD content is not usually played at 60fps, but at 24. Dips under 60 are hardly an issue in this case.

Edit: Heh, about 5 minutes too late with that reply... I really should refresh the pages before attempting to post Smile


Last edited by MinderMast on Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 11:01; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 11:01    Post subject:
MinderMast wrote:
Well, those CPUs+iGPU combos are designed with FullHD playback in mind. There shouldn't be any problems under normal circumstances. FullHD content is not usually played at 60fps, but at 24. Dips under 60 are hardly an issue in this case.


True, but if you want to use Motion² (a function that smooths out the video and makes it looks like it's running @ 60fps) then you need something more powerfull.
Yesterday i even got framedips @ 720p when watching the latest Chuck.

Honestly, i don't see myself watching fullHD movies without Motion², it looks too fucking horrible.


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
MinderMast




Posts: 6172

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 11:03    Post subject:
I let my HDTV handle that, if necessary Smile
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 11:06    Post subject:
My HDTV can't do that (got older type Razz).

But yea, it depends on what mrt has already and what he expects from it Smile


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
[mrt]
[Admin] Code Monkey



Posts: 1342

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 13:03    Post subject:
Mchart wrote:
Just get 8GB. It costs like maybe 10 bucks more for 2 4GB sticks instead of 2 2GB sticks.

Anyways, for a home theater PC I would wait for Ivy Bridge. The iGPU is getting a substantial upgrade with Ivy Bridge.


Aye on the sticks. No use saving up a twenty for such a substantial gain.

Ivy bridge wont be out till april/may. I can't wait that long, I would but I cant. Besides I'm tired of waiting all together. There's always something new around the corner which makes it pointless.

MinderMast wrote:
You shouldn't need a discrete sound card if you intend to use a receiver. The optimal choice for audio output would be over HDMI, which the integrated GPU provides already with full support of all the necessary audio formats.

Furthermore, there won't be any gains in terms of audio quality even if you do get the sound card, since your receiver will be doing all the audio processing. By using HDMI or S/PDIF connections you essentially bypass your sound card.


Makes sense, yea. Didn't even consider it. Perfect.

sausje wrote:
MinderMast wrote:
Well, those CPUs+iGPU combos are designed with FullHD playback in mind. There shouldn't be any problems under normal circumstances. FullHD content is not usually played at 60fps, but at 24. Dips under 60 are hardly an issue in this case.


True, but if you want to use Motion² (a function that smooths out the video and makes it looks like it's running @ 60fps) then you need something more powerfull.
Yesterday i even got framedips @ 720p when watching the latest Chuck.

Honestly, i don't see myself watching fullHD movies without Motion², it looks too fucking horrible.


Hmm though this should be childs play for the integrated GPU. They really hyped up the video transcoding abilities and all that (Virtue). There are quite considerable differences in performance between mobile and desktop processors, altho only the clock difference between the GPUs, so you may have a point. Which kicks up another pebble. Scrape that, get a P67 and spend the cash on a descrete GPU - but which?

The goal is to have smooth playback of any HD or superplusplus HD movies. Buttersmoooooth.


teey
Back to top
Werelds
Special Little Man



Posts: 15098
Location: 0100111001001100
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 13:22    Post subject:
Don't bother with a discrete soundcard. Use S/PDIF or HDMI and just pass the audio through to something that can really deal with it Smile
If your receiver doesn't do DTS-HD or stuff like that, simply have it mixed down to DTS or even DD (all software).

As far as the rest goes, I don't know how good or bad the integrated GPUs are at decoding video in real life.

For the PSU; if you want true silence: get this.
Pricey, but it is completely fanless. Requires good circulation in the case though, PSU has also be in a position where the heat can get out easily in a natural manner (i.e. ventilation holes ABOVE it).
Alternatively: this. Again pricey, but Seasonic's fan control is better than anyone elses; apart from the fact that they just use higher quality parts inside that are more efficient to begin with (so they generate less heat).

All that said, have you considered an alternative option? My HTPC is an E7200 stuffed in an ASUS Pundit barebone. That barebone has an Nvidia GF9400 and 200W fanless PSU. Copes with everything just fine, thanks to CoreAVC Smile

And last but not least: get an SSD. Keep storage on your own PC or a separate little server, but get an SSD to keep that thing completely silent. Got an Onyx 32GB in my HTPC myself, it's just brilliant to be able to boot it (including MediaPortal) in less than 25 seconds whilst not hearing a single sound come out of it Smile
Back to top
Mchart




Posts: 7314

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 13:32    Post subject:
The iGPU will be just fine for playing back 1080p material. In the Virtu control panel I select the iGPU to be used for all video playing applications as then the dGPU doesn't have to spin up just to decode video and I don't get any issues.

I would suspect if people are getting issues with video playback using the iGPU it's a result of something else.
Back to top
[mrt]
[Admin] Code Monkey



Posts: 1342

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 14:57    Post subject:
Werelds wrote:
For the PSU; if you want true silence: get this.
Pricey, but it is completely fanless. Requires good circulation in the case though, PSU has also be in a position where the heat can get out easily in a natural manner (i.e. ventilation holes ABOVE it).
Alternatively: this. Again pricey, but Seasonic's fan control is better than anyone elses; apart from the fact that they just use higher quality parts inside that are more efficient to begin with (so they generate less heat).


Indeed in need of a deeper pocket. I'm looking not to over do it and go all pricy and also not cheap-ass. I'm looking to spend at most 50-60EUR on the PSU. The antec was the first one I found also considering my Antec 350W from a Sonata 5-6years ago still does wonders along with being silent. If there are any same ballpark priced PSUs around that I whizzed by lemme know.

Hmm would that PSU be enough for that configuration? I'm planning of upgrading my main box too, so I can do a little swap-a-roo.

Werelds wrote:
All that said, have you considered an alternative option? My HTPC is an E7200 stuffed in an ASUS Pundit barebone. That barebone has an Nvidia GF9400 and 200W fanless PSU. Copes with everything just fine, thanks to CoreAVC Smile


I have thought about it, but in the end I think i wont save alot of cash buying 2-3 year old hardware. Better shell out now and have lots of popcorn parties pop by before having to upgrade the HTPC. My gut tells me Core Duo's are nearing their end of life, and getting a Pentium G8xx is not too big of a bargain. You subtract some and add the other like the discrete GPU.

Looking across, going for a Phenom X4 may be an option but considering their lack of CPU power and probably higher power draw they'd be noisier in the end and not much cheaper. Integrated GPU's are more powerful tho Very Happy

Werelds wrote:
And last but not least: get an SSD. Keep storage on your own PC or a separate little server, but get an SSD to keep that thing completely silent. Got an Onyx 32GB in my HTPC myself, it's just brilliant to be able to boot it (including MediaPortal) in less than 25 seconds whilst not hearing a single sound come out of it Smile


Sounds heavenly. The plan is though to have the HTPC act as a media server for all the TV's around the house as well along with usual storage. A central dump for every ones crap Smile

DVDRW drive recommendations? Which house should I be looking at, Sonyoptiarc (previously the glorified NEC?), LG, Lite-on, plextor (blast from the past!)...?


teey
Back to top
Werelds
Special Little Man



Posts: 15098
Location: 0100111001001100
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 22:11    Post subject:
[mrt] wrote:
Hmm would that PSU be enough for that configuration? I'm planning of upgrading my main box too, so I can do a little swap-a-roo.

Plenty. Power is the most overestimated part of any build. Right now I have a n i5-760 at 4.2 w/ 6950 at 6970 clocks running off an X-650; previously I had a CM RP 550W. That PSU is still powering my E8400+5870, at one point in time it powered an Intel EE 955 (130W CPU) and 8800 (140W GPU), both overclocked Wink

Phenoms definitely aren't worth it. I only suggested the C2D setup because if you happen to have *any* of them lying around, simply get a G9400 based motherboard and you'll be set.

I do still suggest having an SSD as boot drive if I'm honest. You can still find it and similar SSDs at 40-50 Euros, 30GB is more than plenty for Windows + Office as well; I'll have a look at how much I'm using myself in a bit, but I'm pretty sure 16GB would suffice already. You can still keep that second hard drive for storage - added benefit is that it won't be used during boot, meaning it's not used when it's the noisiest: during Windows' boot and update work Wink

Not sure what to tell you about the DVDRW drives to be honest. I've got a BD-ROM in mine now (my HTPC is literally used for everything: music, TV, films, blurays, DVDs, SD cards from photo cameras, external drives/sticks - everything).
Only thing I can tell you on that front is that no brand has not failed me. I've had NEC, Lite-on, Plextor, different Optiarc based drives (LG, Samsung, ACER, AOC) and they all crapped out on me after a couple years. I recommend NOT spending a lot of cash on that, keep it cheap so that it doesn't hurt when it needs replacing Razz
Back to top
MinderMast




Posts: 6172

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 23:08    Post subject:
In my experience, classifying 30GB as plenty for W7 (x64) and Office is a bit optimistic. I would not feel comfortable with anything less than 50. Obviously, all that space won't get filled up, but I like to have at least a few gigs of free space available all the time.
Back to top
Werelds
Special Little Man



Posts: 15098
Location: 0100111001001100
PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 23:09    Post subject:
MinderMast wrote:
In my experience, classifying 30GB as plenty for W7 (x64) and Office is a bit optimistic. I would not feel comfortable with anything less than 50. Obviously, all that space won't get filled up, but I like to have at least a few gigs of free space available all the time.

My HTPC has been fine for a year and a half on that Onyx now Wink
Back to top
MinderMast




Posts: 6172

PostPosted: Sun, 22nd Jan 2012 23:15    Post subject:
Was just about to add, that considering that this is gonna be media PC, this might suffice since it won't have too much "junk" moving through it Smile

My primary partition tended to creep up to 40+ gigs after months of active use. Although I wasn't overtly restrictive with what I allowed to be installed on it.
Back to top
[mrt]
[Admin] Code Monkey



Posts: 1342

PostPosted: Mon, 23rd Jan 2012 02:24    Post subject:
Werelds wrote:
Plenty. Power is the most overestimated part of any build.


True. Looking that we are far away from the days of the hotcakes such as P4 and Thunderbird. The times where you had to cut out your cheap sheet metal case just to have proper cooling for the bugger. Ahh. I remember finding and running VCool for the first time. I felt a cold breeze as soon as I started it Very Happy. Power draw has been steadily decreasing with CPU's and GPU's alike in a green trend Smile

Crunching the numbers is guess 65W + 25W + 20W + 20W + 10W for CPU, mobo with iGPU, hdd and DVDRW with RAM respectively hardly make up for 150W. Any cheap 650W *cough* PSU can handle that Wink

Werelds wrote:
I do still suggest having an SSD as boot drive if I'm honest. You can still find it and similar SSDs at 40-50 Euros, 30GB is more than plenty for Windows + Office as well


The cheapest I can find here is the Onyx 32GB 1.8" for 87EUR. Agility follows with 60GB at 107EUR. If i could get them that cheap I'd take one certainly. Z68 has a nice hybrid disk cache feature altho I think raid0 would still be on par with it with massively huge chunks of capacity going for it.

Ok good to know, a DVDRW goose chase! I'll make it cheap. I'm good at that Wink


teey
Back to top
Werelds
Special Little Man



Posts: 15098
Location: 0100111001001100
PostPosted: Mon, 23rd Jan 2012 09:57    Post subject:
[mrt] wrote:
Crunching the numbers is guess 65W + 25W + 20W + 20W + 10W for CPU, mobo with iGPU, hdd and DVDRW with RAM respectively hardly make up for 150W. Any cheap 650W *cough* PSU can handle that Wink

Which is kind of my point, might as well settle for something with less wattage but better quality (read: less noise/heat) Wink

Werelds wrote:
If i could get them that cheap I'd take one certainly.

Onyx has been EOL for a very long time already, which is why I said "similar": http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/296130/ocz-vertex-plus-sata-ii-2-komma-5-inch-ssd-30gb.html
There's more like that, just gotta look for them. Speeds aren't that important; sequential speed is completely irrelevant (as you won't be storing data) and even a budget SSD like an Onyx has such incredible random speeds that it's worth it over any mechanical drive Smile

I'm at 24 gigs used in my HTPC. That's 1.5 years worth of Windows updates as well, I'm scared to look at its sxs/wow64 folders. If I format it now and install a clean Win7+SP1 I can probably trim that by a good 7 or 8 gigs, so 16 gigs wouldn't suffice but 30 is definitely more than plenty Smile
Back to top
[mrt]
[Admin] Code Monkey



Posts: 1342

PostPosted: Mon, 23rd Jan 2012 10:45    Post subject:
Really cheap. I can't get ahold of such drives here though. Vertex Plus 60GB being the smallest and going for 80EUR. Thats the difference between you and me. I'd have to go across to wienerland (austria), they have'em. But alot of times that 20EUR just aint worth it hehe.

SSD's should really be getting cheaper now. They keep holding those prices, a dip and they'd be selling like fresh bagles with butter. People would snap one right away for a decent capacity like 120GB, but not for 200EUR. I read yesterday that there was an oversupply of NAND chips last year..huh..it didn't make too much of a dent.


teey
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Mon, 23rd Jan 2012 10:51    Post subject:
[mrt] wrote:
People would snap one right away for a decent capacity like 120GB.


Here 2 friends of mine (and 1 his dad), snapped one when the vertex 3 120gb was on sale for ~130 euro.

Wouldn't it be cheaper to maybe order parts thru someone here and let him send them over? Someone you trust ofc Razz


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
[mrt]
[Admin] Code Monkey



Posts: 1342

PostPosted: Tue, 24th Jan 2012 11:51    Post subject:
Cheaper most definitely, worth it? Probably not. You'd have to nag the dutchie, pay shipping to the dutchie and then shipping from the dutchie to me and when there is at most a 20EUR difference in price, it soon loses it's first strong appeal. I am cheap, but I aint that cheap Wink On top of that I cant take the dutchie out for a pint for doing me a favour.

Warranty becaomes a problem as well, although any EU service should cover it you never know how when those birocrats decide to have a stick up their ass.

I've gotten used to grouching at the prices and grouching at the offers here, but in the end you still end up buying it from the local shelves, although It's really been miserable here. We are the second largest city and every computer store is moving operations to the capitol, from a good dozen shops that were here 10 years ago I think only two or three are left. Only one or two being a regular walk-in shop. Sad :/


teey
Back to top
Werelds
Special Little Man



Posts: 15098
Location: 0100111001001100
PostPosted: Tue, 24th Jan 2012 12:27    Post subject:
No different for sausje or me. Where we live we are basically limited to 2 shops (MyCom, Paradigit). Then there's stuff like MediaMarkt or shit like Dixons, but they don't sell actual components for the most part.
Back to top
sausje
Banned



Posts: 17716
Location: Limboland, Netherlands
PostPosted: Tue, 24th Jan 2012 12:51    Post subject:
I get most my parts from Alternate.nl tho Werelds Razz

Only with my last pc i just looked online what was cheaper in what store, but before EVERYTHING came from Alternate Razz


Proud member of Frustrated Association of International Losers Failing Against the Gifted and Superior (F.A.I.L.F.A.G.S)
Back to top
[mrt]
[Admin] Code Monkey



Posts: 1342

PostPosted: Wed, 25th Jan 2012 02:06    Post subject:
Ok, since i'm going to swap the supplies, I'm stuck between these two,

Antec TruePower TP-650 New for 97EUR

or

Corsair TX650W for 85EUR

So far as I've managed to gather at this late hour is that Antec is in the lead with partial modularity, a more divided (finer control) of the 12V line with a 2A lead but lags behind at 3V3 by as much. The review on SPCR suggests in-between the lines that the Corsair might run a bit hotter than the Antec.

The price difference is tincy and not even worth considering I think, so it boils down to

a.) is someone going to america soon and smuggle-mule the Antec to me for 75$ (i feel like we europeans keep buying free discount cupons for them dollarians with our prices Smile)

b.) Antec is my sweatheart..the truepower in the sonata is still plucking electrons away +1, any votes for the Corsair or any simillar priced models I may have missed?


teey
Back to top
Page 1 of 2 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Hardware Zone Goto page 1, 2  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group