[XBOX360] Firm considers class action over Xbox Live banning
Page 2 of 8 Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8  Next
Mantis2K9




Posts: 676
Location: London,England
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 14:30    Post subject:
Munkeee wrote:
nightlith wrote:
Wow...how is shadow not banned Sad I get banned for trolling less than he does.

The fact is dude, banning from live: I knew the risk and I accepted it. Taking away my DLC (games that I HAVE paid for) is not cool. Your car analogy is flawed. In fact, I'm not even sure where your arguement about quoting the bible came from? Leo didn't say anything about the bible...

I own my house. I renovate (mod) a set of stairs but they don't conform to the safety code (a law). Does that give the law bringers the right to take my home away? No. Microsoft is well within their right to prevent my modded console from going online. They need to protect the online service from hackers and cheats. Destroying my save data, gamertag, and DLC is crossing the line. They're taking games I've paid for away from me. That just can't be legal...

Either way, I am done with 360's. I do hope something starts up here that I can join and get more lawsuits going. I totally endorse fighting back against MS for this...


in the uk, if I build say an extension on my home and it doesn't have planning permission . The council can tell me to pull it down , no relevance to the subject at hand though , different lands and different laws

Also Just because he has a different opinion doesn't mean he's trolling

At first I thought MS was bang out of order but seeing the fallout and the amount of people complain, My view has suddenly changed , mon the microsoft . Get it rite up these pirate cunts


Why?, I agree Microsoft have the right to take away live, and render and live features unusable, dont agree with the other stuff, just seems spiteful to me.

Get what up " these pirate cunts ", why are you here?.
Back to top
Spiderman
Banned



Posts: 5877

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 14:36    Post subject:
ShadowX stop being a cock

xbox bans legal users for :
Volt changes just add a usb fan =BAN
Add a cooling system that uses the xbox power output =BAN
Other hardware(mouse and keyboard plug , different xbox pad thats compatible with the console) used on the Microsoft =BAN
Playing demos or services not from your region =BAN
Broken Power Brick that outputs diffrent voltage = Ban for volt change (whoooot yeah they ban for this shit also stupid fucks)
For OOOOPPPPSSS your on they list but you didn't do anything =BAN

those are the facts ,you don't have to flash your console to be banned those fucks do this to make you BUY A NEW ONE

xbox bans illegal users for :
detecting a DVD-R =ban
HDD spoofing because i will not pay 100$ more for a HDD = BAN
detecting bad key on flashed drive =ban
fixing the laser pot on a DVD because i will not pay 200$ for they repair service when i can fix it for FREE =ban for volt change

uhm yeah and Leo example is 100% correct if you by a car/Laptop or any hardware ITS YOUR FUCKING OWN THING

BUT ok a BAN from the Multiplayer aspect i can live without it,M$ goes beyond they rights yeah:
burns a fuse on the mainboard with a SOFTWARE UPDATE to disable HomeBrew Linux Support
Disables HDD functionality
Disables MP3 listing
Corrupts saves and profile
Disables Movie Playback
Reverts ALL YOUR BOUGHT Games on XBLA to DEMOS


I get that the new car models have the same shit with they locked CPU controlled engines,


Securom Internet activation Shit
STEAM SHIT
and now this SHIT
THIS HAS TO STOP

if those are the actions to stop used games sales and piracy THEY SHOULD CHECK THEY HEADS
Back to top
Munkeee




Posts: 1131

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 14:44    Post subject:
Mantis2K9 wrote:


Why?, I agree Microsoft have the right to take away live, and render and live features unusable, dont agree with the other stuff, just seems spiteful to me.

Get what up " these pirate cunts ", why are you here?.


Because I don't agree with a bunch of whinging spoilt brats who think ms owe them something I shouldn't be here ?

You accept that they have the ability to remove functionality of certain things yet you complain when it doesn't suit you . Hdd installs where an added bonus in nxe , you lost it just like you lost the ability to share your profile directly with other consoles

your hd still works on the banned console
your gamertag still works fine on banned console

They blacklisted the console so it can't sign , you prove that console can't exactly be trusted...

Spiderman wrote:
ShadowX stop being a cock

xbox bans legal users for :
Volt changes just add a usb fan =BAN
Add a cooling system that uses the xbox power output =BAN
Other hardware(mouse and keyboard plug , different xbox pad thats compatible with the console) used on the Microsoft =BAN
Playing demos or services not from your region =BAN
Broken Power Brick that outputs diffrent voltage = Ban for volt change (whoooot yeah they ban for this shit also stupid fucks)
For OOOOPPPPSSS your on they list but you didn't do anything =BAN

those are the fact

you don't have to flash your console to be banned those fucks do this to make you BUY A NEW ONE

xbox bans illegal users for :
detecting a DVD-R =ban
HDD spoofing because i will not pay 100$ more for a HDD = BAN
detecting bad key on flashed drive =ban
fixing the laser pot on a DVD because i will not pay 200$ for they repair service when i can fix it for FREE =ban for volt change

uhm yeah and Leo example is 100% correctS


And you tell shadowx to stop being a "cock" ?


sabin1981 wrote:
but you know what Chinese whispers are like; some newbie will read your comment and suddenly run and spread it all over the internet that the new 2010 Banwave disables all your XBLA games when you're banned.

Ironic Statement #4756 from sabin


Last edited by Munkeee on Sat, 21st Nov 2009 14:50; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
deelix
PDIP Member



Posts: 32062
Location: Norway
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 14:49    Post subject:
the absolute worst part is people who have bought arcade games, and now just have a bunch of trail games. Thats just wrong
Back to top
WankStaiNuK




Posts: 820
Location: England, UK
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 15:32    Post subject:
[quote="ShadowX IM PATHETIC[/quote]

Yes you are


Back to top
Mantis2K9




Posts: 676
Location: London,England
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 15:44    Post subject:
Munkeee wrote:


Because I don't agree with a bunch of whinging spoilt brats who think ms owe them something I shouldn't be here ?

People arent whinging about Xbox live being take away, its the stuff they paid for being rendered unusable.

You accept that they have the ability to remove functionality of certain things yet you complain when it doesn't suit you . Hdd installs where an added bonus in nxe , you lost it just like you lost the ability to share your profile directly with other consoles

No I am complaining because all the stuff I paid for is not working or is usable, Xbox live is my problem.

your hd still works on the banned console
your gamertag still works fine on banned console

And?

They blacklisted the console so it can't sign , you prove that console can't exactly be trusted...

Eh?



And you tell shadowx to stop being a "cock" ?[/quote]

Yes he is acting like a prick, and you are on a site where you can view the NFO's of crack group releases, but take a moral stance of some kind, cant work that out?.
Back to top
Munkeee




Posts: 1131

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 16:00    Post subject:
Whats not to work out , you deserved the ban and they revoked your right to install games and sign gamesaves

DLC should work if it was the console it was bought on , plenty of people I know dlc still work same goes for lots of xbox-scene users . if its not the console the license is signed too ( ie bought with another console , you shared an account for instance , check licence migration for instance ) then it won't work as it needs to have the live connection to validate it


sabin1981 wrote:
but you know what Chinese whispers are like; some newbie will read your comment and suddenly run and spread it all over the internet that the new 2010 Banwave disables all your XBLA games when you're banned.

Ironic Statement #4756 from sabin


Last edited by Munkeee on Sat, 21st Nov 2009 16:02; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 16:02    Post subject:
Munkeee wrote:
they revoked your right to install games and sign save games


They have no right to do either as neither relate to the Live service itself.

Quote:

DLC should work if it was the console it was bought on


Yeah? Well it doesn't, but no doubt you'll turn round and say people deserve to lose their DLC/XBLA titles too, right? Rolling Eyes
Back to top
Mantis2K9




Posts: 676
Location: London,England
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 16:05    Post subject:
Munkeee wrote:
Whats not to work out , you deserved the ban and they revoked your right to install games and sign gamesaves

DLC should work if it was the console it was bought on , plenty of people I know dlc still work same goes for lots of xbox-scene users . if its not the console the license is signed too ( ie bought with another console , you shared an account for instance , check licence migration for instance ) then it won't work as it needs to have the live connection to validate it


No, the liscence relates to being banned on Xbox live, not the revoking of bought software.

Read the liscence agreements.
Back to top
Munkeee




Posts: 1131

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 16:06    Post subject:
sabin1981 wrote:
Munkeee wrote:
they revoked your right to install games and sign save games


They have no right to do either as neither relate to the Live service itself.

Quote:

DLC should work if it was the console it was bought on


Yeah? Well it doesn't, but no doubt you'll turn round and say people deserve to lose their DLC/XBLA titles too, right? Rolling Eyes


1. your saves work fine , they limit them to your banned console . boo fucking hoo . they also remove the install feature which they have every right

2. it works , check xbox-scene forums . I'll believe what people tell me and the info i read there before I believe your half arsed fucking ideas. I'm not gonna fucking c+p every bit of info like i had to do with the hdd install disables , the hddss.bin fiasco or fucking fuses

3. Do me a fucking favour and ignore me , twice you have stated you have so please fucking add me to your ignore list

4. What the fuck is it with you and the rolleyes smilies . are you a fucking epileptic in real life or something




Just asked someone to try an arcade game for me their on their newly banned console . seems braid and splosion man is contrary to your beliefs as they both seemed to boot fine


sabin1981 wrote:
but you know what Chinese whispers are like; some newbie will read your comment and suddenly run and spread it all over the internet that the new 2010 Banwave disables all your XBLA games when you're banned.

Ironic Statement #4756 from sabin


Last edited by Munkeee on Sat, 21st Nov 2009 16:27; edited 2 times in total
Back to top
ShadowX




Posts: 1273

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 16:12    Post subject:
People may call me names I dont care I just said my opinion here about this , you buy a xbox and with that you agree with there rules.
You get banned for doing something that isnt allowed then thats to bad but no need to blame MS , afterall it was the people own desision to modded there console and it was you all that desided to break there rules and law says dont pirate.

To the ones that wants to have me banned I ask you ban for what ? , for saying my opinion on a post in a normal way , I dont call names I respect the rules here and just say that people shouldnt whine because they are banned for something they knew that could happen.


I also said it sucks if it happends to you but then buy 2 xboxes , use one for the online gaming and the other for the games you download.

Dont tell me you cant affort that cause when you download 3 games you already saved enough cash to buy one.

For this reason I got 3 xboxes , one for my wife and one for me (wich we use both for online gaming) and one for my son for offline gaming wich is modded , he plays online games on the PC.

Ones more Im just saying my opinion, if you dont agree fine but no need to call me names or tell me im trolling.

Also thanks to the people that do understand what i`m saying , I do know that alot probaly dont agree but those are the ones that are banned so yaah its understandable.


Last edited by ShadowX on Sat, 21st Nov 2009 17:49; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
nightlith




Posts: 744
Location: Land of Bagged Milk
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 17:37    Post subject:
Well, there's a big difference in what you say and how you say it. At least that last post was more clear and concise.

Regardless, I just want my arcade games that I purchased back Sad I spent good money on that stuff and MS is being real dicks about the whole Live thing. At least put the license validation server on a seperate connection not tied into live Sad Fucking cunts.


i can has computar?!
Back to top
ShadowX




Posts: 1273

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 17:50    Post subject:
nightlith wrote:
Well, there's a big difference in what you say and how you say it. At least that last post was more clear and concise.

Regardless, I just want my arcade games that I purchased back Sad I spent good money on that stuff and MS is being real dicks about the whole Live thing. At least put the license validation server on a seperate connection not tied into live Sad Fucking cunts.



Regardless or not that they disabled the modded console you knew up front what could happen yet people still deside to mod it anyway , I mean why whine if they knew what could happen, basicly its part of the risk people take.

About your downloads they still out there , all you have to do is get a unmodded console and they still work.
Back to top
Spiderman
Banned



Posts: 5877

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 18:05    Post subject:
Cool Face
i got a MS employees wive be here
Back to top
madmax17




Posts: 19052
Location: Croatia
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 18:28    Post subject:
Spiderman wrote:
ShadowX stop being a cock

xbox bans legal users for :
Volt changes just add a usb fan =BAN
Add a cooling system that uses the xbox power output =BAN
Other hardware(mouse and keyboard plug , different xbox pad thats compatible with the console) used on the Microsoft =BAN
Playing demos or services not from your region =BAN
Broken Power Brick that outputs diffrent voltage = Ban for volt change (whoooot yeah they ban for this shit also stupid fucks)
For OOOOPPPPSSS your on they list but you didn't do anything =BAN

those are the facts ,you don't have to flash your console to be banned those fucks do this to make you BUY A NEW ONE

xbox bans illegal users for :
detecting a DVD-R =ban
HDD spoofing because i will not pay 100$ more for a HDD = BAN
detecting bad key on flashed drive =ban
fixing the laser pot on a DVD because i will not pay 200$ for they repair service when i can fix it for FREE =ban for volt change

uhm yeah and Leo example is 100% correct if you by a car/Laptop or any hardware ITS YOUR FUCKING OWN THING

BUT ok a BAN from the Multiplayer aspect i can live without it,M$ goes beyond they rights yeah:
burns a fuse on the mainboard with a SOFTWARE UPDATE to disable HomeBrew Linux Support
Disables HDD functionality
Disables MP3 listing
Corrupts saves and profile
Disables Movie Playback
Reverts ALL YOUR BOUGHT Games on XBLA to DEMOS


I get that the new car models have the same shit with they locked CPU controlled engines,


Securom Internet activation Shit
STEAM SHIT
and now this SHIT
THIS HAS TO STOP

if those are the actions to stop used games sales and piracy THEY SHOULD CHECK THEY HEADS
M$ is full of shit you can't fart unless they give you permission, the xbox is a communist console, if only ps3 was hackable I wouldn't think twice about it.
Back to top
dezztroy




Posts: 6590
Location: Sweden
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 18:44    Post subject:
ShadowX wrote:
nightlith wrote:
Well, there's a big difference in what you say and how you say it. At least that last post was more clear and concise.

Regardless, I just want my arcade games that I purchased back Sad I spent good money on that stuff and MS is being real dicks about the whole Live thing. At least put the license validation server on a seperate connection not tied into live Sad Fucking cunts.



Regardless or not that they disabled the modded console you knew up front what could happen yet people still deside to mod it anyway , I mean why whine if they knew what could happen, basicly its part of the risk people take.

About your downloads they still out there , all you have to do is get a unmodded console and they still work.


What you don't seem to get is, the only risk there is supposed to be, is getting banned from using the LIVE service. They have no right legally to disable any other features of our boxes. Noone is whining because they can't use LIVE anymore, we're whining because MS is breaking the law.
Back to top
WHEATTHlNS




Posts: 1137

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 19:19    Post subject:
Quote:
People may call me names I dont care I just said my opinion here about this , you buy a xbox and with that you agree with there rules.


You're being called "names" because you are attempting to extrapolate one part of the EULA, which gives Microsoft (rightfully) the power to limit access to its Live Service, with the ability to hobble hardware functionality. I personally was not aware that XBLA games, HDD installing, etc. was connected to the Live Service. I'm sure you know it is not.

The lawsuit may not go anywhere, but its hardly a case that has no merits. Modifying ones console to play burned games is not against the law. Distributing digitally copyrighted material is. The two are NOT the same.


"Get the hell out of me" - [ex]girlfriend[s]
Back to top
ShadowX




Posts: 1273

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 20:11    Post subject:
dezztroy wrote:
ShadowX wrote:
nightlith wrote:
Well, there's a big difference in what you say and how you say it. At least that last post was more clear and concise.

Regardless, I just want my arcade games that I purchased back Sad I spent good money on that stuff and MS is being real dicks about the whole Live thing. At least put the license validation server on a seperate connection not tied into live Sad Fucking cunts.



Regardless or not that they disabled the modded console you knew up front what could happen yet people still deside to mod it anyway , I mean why whine if they knew what could happen, basicly its part of the risk people take.

About your downloads they still out there , all you have to do is get a unmodded console and they still work.


What you don't seem to get is, the only risk there is supposed to be, is getting banned from using the LIVE service. They have no right legally to disable any other features of our boxes. Noone is whining because they can't use LIVE anymore, we're whining because MS is breaking the law.



And wich part didnt you get of my early replies , mod the fucker who gives a shit but on the moment you throw it online you knew upfront what could happen.

Simple mod it , flash it who cares just dont go online and you be fine , and dont tell me you didnt knew all this when you modded it.
Back to top
KrutojPoc




Posts: 1528

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 21:33    Post subject:
Guys, why don't you sue MS? I mean, they are rich, you can ask for a good compensation. They can't do this, they can't do that...ok fine just go and sue them, what's the problem? It looks like you don't actually believe in what you say, that's why you bitch, cause that's all you can do.
MS is a huge and rich company, thousands of people are waiting for an opportunity to sue it's ass because of money. I am sure MS double checks all their actions are legal before they do something. That's why i don't believe their recent actions are illegal. But you seem to be so sure MS is guilty, just go and take your money then. You can't lose Smile
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 21:39    Post subject:
KrutojPoc wrote:
I am sure MS double checks all their actions are legal before they do something. That's why i don't believe their recent actions are illegal.



Back to top
KrutojPoc




Posts: 1528

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 21:45    Post subject:
What? Ok i can do that too

Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 21:54    Post subject:
Dude, read back what you just typed. Read it carefully and then repeat i back to yourself. Speak it out loud, go on.

"I am sure MS double checks all their actions are legal before they do something"

Ok, so do that and - once you've stopped ROTFLing - come back and post again. Laughing
Back to top
Kommando




Posts: 4863
Location: Vinland
PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 21:55    Post subject:
ShadowX wrote:


And wich part didnt you get of my early replies , mod the fucker who gives a shit but on the moment you throw it online you knew upfront what could happen.

Simple mod it , flash it who cares just dont go online and you be fine , and dont tell me you didnt knew all this when you modded it.


Kind of tired of your attitude here. Banning from their services for having a modded console its fine by me but to screw up YOUR hardware in the process is illegal.

So if i follow your way of thinking and i am a car company. I found out that Mr. X tweaked the shit out of my car, it will be ok for me to go to his home and filled his gas tank with sugar???

They have no rights to brick hardware PERIOD!!!
Back to top
Munkeee




Posts: 1131

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 22:02    Post subject:
Kommando wrote:
ShadowX wrote:


And wich part didnt you get of my early replies , mod the fucker who gives a shit but on the moment you throw it online you knew upfront what could happen.

Simple mod it , flash it who cares just dont go online and you be fine , and dont tell me you didnt knew all this when you modded it.


Kind of tired of your attitude here. Banning from their services for having a modded console its fine by me but to screw up YOUR hardware in the process is illegal.

So if i follow your way of thinking and i am a car company. I found out that Mr. X tweaked the shit out of my car, it will be ok for me to go to his home and filled his gas tank with sugar???

They have no rights to brick hardware PERIOD!!!


1. Its your profile , nothing done to YOUR hardware
2. They didn't brick your hard drive PERIOD!!!


sabin1981 wrote:
but you know what Chinese whispers are like; some newbie will read your comment and suddenly run and spread it all over the internet that the new 2010 Banwave disables all your XBLA games when you're banned.

Ironic Statement #4756 from sabin
Back to top
KrutojPoc




Posts: 1528

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 22:04    Post subject:
sabin1981 wrote:
Dude, read back what you just typed. Read it carefully and then repeat i back to yourself. Speak it out loud, go on.

"I am sure MS double checks all their actions are legal before they do something"

Ok, so do that and - once you've stopped ROTFLing - come back and post again. Laughing


I don't understand. Is there a mistake or something, cause english is not my native language. I hope you understand what i am trying to say, and that's not funny at all
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 22:08    Post subject:
KrutojPoc wrote:

I don't understand. Is there a mistake or something, cause english is not my native language. I hope you understand what i am trying to say, and that's not funny at all


I'll break it down for you nice and easy; Microsoft breaks the law. Daily. Weekly. Monthly. Yearly. That's what they do - it's why they get fined and sued for MILLIONS, all the frakking time Laughing They've just been fined MILLIONS for the illegal usage, theft, of the XML code that has been used in MS Office. They've been prohibited from selling any and all copies of MS Officer 2007 and above.

My god.. please dude, please tell me you're just kidding, just trolling for lulz, and that you seriously DON'T believe that MS do everything legally Laughing
Back to top
KrutojPoc




Posts: 1528

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 22:22    Post subject:
sabin1981 wrote:
KrutojPoc wrote:

I don't understand. Is there a mistake or something, cause english is not my native language. I hope you understand what i am trying to say, and that's not funny at all


I'll break it down for you nice and easy; Microsoft breaks the law. Daily. Weekly. Monthly. Yearly. That's what they do - it's why they get fined and sued for MILLIONS, all the frakking time Laughing They've just been fined MILLIONS for the illegal usage, theft, of the XML code that has been used in MS Office. They've been prohibited from selling any and all copies of MS Officer 2007 and above.

My god.. please dude, please tell me you're just kidding, just trolling for lulz, and that you seriously DON'T believe that MS do everything legally Laughing


Then why the fuck are you still here? You should be in the court. Yes they are sued cause they are rich as fuck and there's always someone trying to get their money, same with EA, Sony and other rich companies, it's not just MS who constantly gets sued. That's why every rich company double checks their actions are legal, what's so funny about it? People always find holes in the laws and sue companies. One, two, even ten lawsuits is fine but thousands is a disaster. MS just banned almost 1mil of people and these people are pissed off. Think about it before calling other people trolls
Back to top
sabin1981
Mostly Cursed



Posts: 87805

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 22:25    Post subject:
Oh my god, you really DO believe MS don't do anything illegal!



You're priceless man. I see I'm wasting my time here. Enjoy keeping your head in the sand.
Back to top
KrutojPoc




Posts: 1528

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 22:39    Post subject:
sabin1981 wrote:
Oh my god, you really DO believe MS don't do anything illegal!



You're priceless man. I see I'm wasting my time here. Enjoy keeping your head in the sand.


Where did i say something like that? If MS loses in the court, that makes their actions illegal, right? So obviosly MS doesn't do everything legal, cause they lose sometimes and pay fine or compensation. BUT that doesn't mean they don't do everything possible to avoid lawsuits, especially massive lawsuits you can expect when you ban 1 mil of people, is it too difficult to understand?
Back to top
Tungsten




Posts: 2020

PostPosted: Sat, 21st Nov 2009 22:45    Post subject:
there is no way in hell M$ r going to lose this lawsuit. whether they pay someone off, or whatever, if they lose this, they would be screwed
Back to top
Page 2 of 8 All times are GMT + 1 Hour
NFOHump.com Forum Index - Console Arena Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8  Next
Signature/Avatar nuking: none (can be changed in your profile)  


Display posts from previous:   

Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB 2.0.8 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group